'The Legend of Billie Jean'
The Ringer's Bill Simmons and Chris Ryan shave their heads and go on the lam to revisit the 1985 'one-for-us' hall-of-famer 'The Legend of Billie Jean,' starring Helen Slater, Christian Slater, and Keith Gordon.

Cast
Helen Slater as Billie Jean Davy
Christian Slater as Binx
Peter Coyote as Detective Ringwald
Keith Gordon as Lloyd
Notes
- ~401st Rewatchables episode ('American Gangster' was the 400th the previous week). Aired during NFL Week 1.
- Grossed only $3.1 million (flopped theatrically) – became a VHS/cable cult classic.
- Produced by John Peters and Peter Guber. Original title was 'Fair is Fair.'
- Christian Slater's film debut (age 15). He and Helen Slater are not related but were reportedly close during filming.
- Cinematographer: Jeffrey Kimball (also shot 'Top Gun').
- Pat Benatar called this 'the worst movie ever made' but still performs 'Invincible' at concerts.
- Shot entirely on location in Corpus Christi using ~85 real locations. The Sunrise Mall and miniature golf course used in the film are now gone.
- No budget recorded and no Roger Ebert review.
- The Duffer Brothers (Stranger Things) are believed to have studied this film – Eleven's haircut, the synth score, the '80s kid aesthetic.
Categories
- Bill: Billie Jean getting exchanged across Texas as Pat Benatar's 'Invincible' plays for 5 full minutes. 'One of those rare 80s sequences where the song completely drives the scene.'
- CR: The scene at Lloyd's house where Billie Jean emerges with her new haircut and makes the tape – 'you look famous.'
- Also nominated: Opening credits with Divinyls' 'Boys in Town'; the golf course chase; the mini-mall exchange gone wrong.
- Bill: The authentic beta movie camera; Honda Elite scooter; Panama Jack sunscreen stand; gas at $1.05; watching a wall of TVs in a store.
- CR: Jimmy J Judge on C101 Talk Radio as a local DJ – peak 1985 local media.
- Craig: The haircut itself – 'the most 1985 element.'
- Mr. Pyatt as an amazing 80s villain; exchange scenes in an 80s mall going wrong.
- Young Christian Slater (his film debut); Billie Jean's haircut becoming a local phenomenon.
- Characters getting mad their ransom was too low (Lloyd: 'Only 10K?').
- Lloyd's hostage plan as an inventive way to try to get laid.
- '80s high school bad guys (Hubie's crew); hiding in empty suburban mansions.
- The Slaters looking like real siblings despite not being related.
- Dreaming of living in Vermont; the way adults talk to Billie Jean (casual misogyny).
- A good old boy shooting at Billie Jean with a hunting rifle to get ransom money.
- Helen Slater's wig in reshoots (looked like Steve Kerr's '98 Bulls hair).
- Pat Benatar saying it was 'the worst movie ever made.'
- By far: 'Invincible' by Pat Benatar – played 3 full times in the movie, completely iconic.
- Also: Divinyls' 'Boys in Town' (opening credits); Billy Idol's 'Rebel Yell.'
- Big wide shot of them lying on wood in the lake.
- Craig: The hair reveal shot starting in the pool – shot by Jeffrey Kimball ('Top Gun' DP).
- Bill: Billie Jean saving Kenny the abused kid subplot, or the scene where people shoot at her for ransom.
- CR: Yeardley Smith's character getting her period for no story reason.
Bill: Putter's mom. CR: Kenny's dad.
- Bill: This movie is prescient about viral celebrity culture, internet fame, and citizen journalism – 'the movie that created the Internet.'
- CR: The movie didn't need a love interest (Lloyd) – it weakened the female empowerment theme.
- Bill: Richard Bradford (Mr. Pyatt – also in 'The Untouchables').
- CR: Barry Tubb (Wolfman in 'Top Gun').
- Winner: Yeardley Smith / Putter (who later became Lisa Simpson).
- Helen Slater: Debated between this, Supergirl, Secret of My Success, and 'City Slickers'.
- Christian Slater: Yes (film debut).
- Honda Elite scooters: Yes (Lou Reed did their ad in '85).
- Self-haircuts in movies: Yes.
- Peter Coyote: Probably E.T.
- Yeardley Smith: The Simpsons.
- Short-haired '80s women: Yes.
Not extensively discussed.
Scorsese version would add cocaine dealing for Mr. Pyatt.
Bill: Hubie. Craig: Also Hubie.
- Too many detectives working this case in Corpus Christi.
- Hubie repeatedly obstructing justice with no consequences.
- The kids would have been caught in 45 minutes – they never left Corpus Christi.
- Binx buying an expensive scooter with no bike lock in a trailer park.
- Sharpshooters at the rally taking orders from the DA, not the police chief.
Discussed briefly – probably no one since the movie made $3.1 million.
The Honda Elite scooter. Also: the 'Fair is Fair' T-shirts.
'Fair's fair.'
- Bill: 'The Terminator' (female empowerment heroes).
- CR: Last Starfighter or Rad (cult VHS classics).
Helen Slater (with Pat Benatar/'Invincible' as an alternative).
Craig had never seen or heard of the movie before. His flex: 'What happens the next day' – in 2025, Billie Jean would go on a Hawk Tuah podcast and release music by 25.