Rewatchables Reference

If you could own one prop, costume, or piece of memorabilia from the movie, what would it be? And what would you absolutely not want? The hosts pick items they'd display proudly in their homes and items they wouldn't touch with a ten-foot pole.

This category is a fun window into each host's personality. Some go for the iconic props (the briefcase from 'Pulp Fiction', the trunks from 'Rocky'), others go practical (a car, a piece of jewelry), and some go deliberately weird. The "not want" picks are often the funniest – who wants the cursed item or the blood-soaked outfit?

This category officially debuted on 'The American President' episode, although it technically appeared first on the 'Rocky IV' episode, which was recorded before 'The American President' – but was only released 2 years later, in 2022.

Since the hosts chose cars too often, cars were eventually banned from this category, and later a limitation was put into place that the memorabilia had to fit through your front door (so that you couldn't choose something like a house).

The "not want" twist was suggested by a listener in A 2025 Rewatchables Mailbag episode.