Best "that guy"
The hosts pick the best "that guy" (or "that gal") in the movie – the character actor you definitely recognize from a dozen other things but probably can't name. These are the unsung heroes of cinema: the faces that populate the backgrounds and supporting casts of countless films, making every movie they're in a little bit better.
A great "that guy" pick is someone who makes you point at the screen and say "oh, it's THAT guy!" They might be famous to cinephiles but unknown to casual moviegoers. The category celebrates the deep bench of working character actors who are the backbone of Hollywood.
This category has been a staple of the show since pretty much the beginning, appearing officially for the first time in the original 'Departed' episode, although conversations about "that guy" are present even in the pre-Rewatchables 'Heat' episode on the Bill Simmon's podcast.
The award is called the "Joey Pants award" after Joe Pantoliano, whose run in the '80s and '90s is legendary.