November 05, 2024

'Body Double'

The Ringer's Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, and Sean Fennessey head to the adult section for a copy of 'Holly Does Hollywood' on VHS after rewatching Brian De Palma's 1984 erotic thriller 'Body Double,' starring Craig Wasson and Melanie Griffith.

Movie poster

Cast

Craig Wasson as Jake Scully

Melanie Griffith as Holly Body

Gregg Henry as Sam Bouchard

Dennis Franz as Rubin

Deborah Shelton as Gloria Revelle

Barbara Crampton as Jake's girlfriend

Steven Bauer as Male porn actor

Directed by: Brian De Palma

Written by: Robert Avrech

Cinematography by: Stephen H. Burum

Music by: Pino Donaggio

Notes

  • Budget of $10 million; grossed $8.8 million – a commercial flop that became one of the most influential movies of the 1980s.
  • De Palma originally planned it to be the first Hollywood film with unsimulated sex scenes; Columbia said no.
  • Bret Easton Ellis made 'Body Double' Patrick Bateman's favorite movie in American Psycho (rented 37 times on video cassette).
  • The Chemosphere house (designed by John Lautner, built 1960) is a real house off Mulholland Drive.
  • PTA's 'Boogie Nights' heavily borrowed from this film: the walk-in-on-cheating scene, the porn industry milieu, and the Sid Goldberg show structure.
  • A real porn actress named Holly Body later took her stage name from this film.
  • Released the same day as 'The Terminator' (October 26, 1984).
  • Dennis Franz appeared in five straight De Palma films; Gregg Henry appeared in five total.
  • Gloria Revelle's voice was dubbed by Helen Shaver because Deborah Shelton's performance wasn't usable.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

An exhilarating exercise in pure filmmaking. A thriller in the Hitchcock tradition.

Pauline Kael hated it: called it 'an awful disappointment' – she felt betrayed by De Palma, whom she had defended.

Most re-watchable scene
  • Bill: everything from when Jake sees the porn video through to the first date with Holly Body.
  • Chris: the casting of Jake into the porn film and the Frankie Goes to Hollywood / 'Relax' sequence.
  • Sean: the 'Relax' sequence (most rewatched), but his favorite scene is 'The Follow' – Jake trailing Gloria through the Rodeo Collection mall.
The most 1984 thing about this movie
  • Chris: porn video stores / Power Records.
  • Sean: the adult section of those video stores.
  • Bill: putting a music video inside the movie.
What aged the best?
  • Young Melanie Griffith – fun to see her before she became a massive star (Bill).
  • The movie itself – a flop that became 'literally one of the most influential movies of the 1980s' on filmmakers like Soderbergh, Fincher, Tarantino, PTA (Sean).
  • Craig Wasson looks like 'Bill Maher crossed with Breckin Meyer' (Bill).
What aged the worst?
  • Calling the killer 'the Indian' throughout the movie.
  • Jake not having sex with Holly and instead spilling the beans about the murder.
  • Sam's absurdly elaborate murder conspiracy/plan (Chris).
Most cinematic shot
  • Chris: the diopter shot of Jake and Gloria at the pay phone from the valet area.
  • Also: the entire follow/mall sequence, the tunnel, the reservoir staging, the 360-degree kiss on the beach.
Best needle drop
  • 'Relax' by Frankie Goes to Hollywood – unanimous pick. Bill: first time he'd seen an MTV-style video correctly integrated into a movie.
  • Pino Donaggio's score praised by Chris: 'Beautiful.'
Weak link of the movie

The reservoir ending – Bill: 'just ridiculous, they kind of ran out of time.' Chris: someone needed to tell De Palma 'this is going to look cool but makes no sense.'

The hottest take award
  • Chris: Jake should have stayed in porn – 'He's doing on-camera feature work after one audition.'
  • Sean: 'We should be having unsimulated sex in movies.'
  • Bill: this is the best integration of the porn world into a mainstream movie ever.
Casting what-ifs
  • Linda Hamilton turned down Holly Body to do 'The Terminator' (same release date).
  • Jamie Lee Curtis was rumored/considered; Griffith introduced De Palma to Curtis, who said no.
  • Annette Haven (real porn star) was seriously considered for Holly Body; De Palma spent extensive time with her.
  • For Jake: Tom Hanks discussed as potentially perfect (the Jimmy Stewart 'ordinary man').
Over-acting award
  • Saul Rubinek as the director: 'I treated you like a son, you fucking stab me in the heart.'
  • The police detective who interrogates Jake after the murder (Bill).
Best "that guy"
  • Bill's pick: Sid Goldberg (the porn TV show host).
  • Also: Larry Flash Jenkins, Dennis Franz, Barbara Crampton.
Apex Mountain
  • Craig Wasson: definitively 'Body Double' – 'first line of his obituary' (Chris).
  • Melanie Griffith: 'Working Girl'.
  • Brian De Palma: Scarface (Sean).
  • Gregg Henry: this movie.
  • Frankie Goes to Hollywood: definitely this / 'Relax' era.
Cruise or Hanks?
Hanks wins

Hanks plays Jake Scully (everyman loser). Cruise plays Sam Bouchard (smarmy, slick).

Picking nits
  • Sam's plan is absurdly overcomplicated (multiple cars, costumes, 3.5 hours of makeup, the house, the body double dancer).
  • Why did Sam pick the most famous porn star (Holly Body) as the decoy dancer instead of someone less recognizable?
  • Jake kept Gloria's underpants in his pocket for 10 hours.
  • Getting into porn in 1984 – was it really that easy to become the lead actor with one audition?
Just one Oscar, who gets it?
  • Bill: Melanie Griffith, Best Supporting Actress.
  • Chris: Stephen Burum (cinematography).
  • Sean: Brian De Palma (director).
(Probably) unanswerable questions

Is it possible Jake imagined the whole movie? All three hosts think it's plausible.

What memorabilia would you want (or not want!) from the movie?

Sean: the drill. Chris: the Indian prosthetic mask. Bill: a Holly Does Hollywood video cassette.

Best (or worst!) life lessons from the movie
  • Don't trust anyone you barely know who offers you a house-sitting gig (Bill).
  • If it's too good to be true, it probably is (Chris).
  • Don't follow strangers for long periods of time to Long Beach (Sean).
Best double feature for this movie
  • Sean: Vertigo (Hitchcock) – 'they're very similar.'
  • Bill: 'Working Girl' (Melanie Griffith before-and-after double feature) or Dressed to Kill.
Who won the movie?
  • Melanie Griffith wins (Sean and Bill agree). She becomes a major star after this – Something Wild, 'Working Girl'.
  • Chris: De Palma.