October 15, 2024

'The Silence of the Lambs' live from Broadway

Live from inside a hospital for the criminally insane, The Ringer's Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, Sean Fennessey, and Mallory Rubin revisit the award-winning 1991 film 'The Silence of the Lambs,' starring Jodie Foster, Anthony Hopkins, and Ted Levine.

Movie poster

Cast

Jodie Foster as Clarice Starling

Anthony Hopkins as Dr. Hannibal Lecter

Ted Levine as Jame Gumb / Buffalo Bill

Scott Glenn as Jack Crawford

Anthony Heald as Dr. Frederick Chilton

Brooke Smith as Catherine Martin

Diane Baker as Senator Ruth Martin

Frankie Faison as Barney

Stuart Rudin as Multiple Miggs

Charles Napier as Lt. Boyle

Chris Isaak as SWAT Commander

Kasi Lemmons as Ardelia Mapp

Directed by: Jonathan Demme

Written by: Ted Tally

Cinematography by: Tak Fujimoto

Music by: Howard Shore

Notes

  • $19 million budget, $272.7 million box office (4th biggest of 1991). First and only horror film to win Best Picture.
  • Third film to win the 'Big 5' (Picture, Director, Actor, Actress, Screenplay), after It Happened One Night and One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest.
  • Hopkins had the second-least screen time for a Best Actor winner: 24 minutes, 52 seconds. He beat De Niro, Robin Williams, Warren Beatty, and Nick Nolte.
  • Ted Levine was not nominated for Supporting Actor. Jack Palance won that year for 'City Slickers'.
  • Hopkins created Lecter's accent as a cross between Truman Capote, HAL from 2001, and Katharine Hepburn. He said: 'Stillness is the key. If you stare at someone for more than 10 seconds, it scares them.'
  • Demme told Hopkins to think of Lecter as 'the devil: charming, witty, clever and wise, seductive, sexual and lethal. But he's also a gentleman.'
  • Ted Levine came up with the tuck dance himself. He initially performed it to Bob Seger's 'Her Strut' before it was changed to 'Goodbye Horses.'
  • William Goldman story: at a screening for 75 Hollywood people, Goldman told Demme to cut a 12-minute scene. Demme resisted, tried it, and Goldman was right.
  • Dino De Laurentiis ('Manhunter' producer) gave away the Lecter rights for free.
  • Buffalo Bill was based on Ed Gein (skinning), Gary Heidnik (pit), and Ted Bundy.
  • Brooke Smith gained 25 lbs to become a size 14. Years later the prop lady sent her a bottle of lotion: 'It puts the lotion on its skin.'
  • The movie arguably kicked off a four-decade true crime boom and glamorized serial killers as leads.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

It's been a good long while since I felt the presence of evil so manifestly demonstrated.

Ebert gave it 3.5 stars (not 4). Siskel gave it a thumbs down, writing: 'Foster's character is dwarfed by the monster she is after.'

Most re-watchable scene
  • CR and Bill: Lecter attacks the two guards (the escape sequence).
  • Mallory: The Crying of the Lambs story – Clarice's confession to Lecter.
  • Sean: The first Clarice-Lecter encounter (including Miggs).
  • Also discussed: Catherine Martin singing 'American Girl' into the kidnapping van; 'Put the lotion in the basket'; the tuck dance; the night vision goggles basement scene; 'I'm having an old friend for dinner.'
What aged the best?
  • Chilton as the 'Mayor Brody trope' – the obvious human villain alongside the serial killer villain.
  • The visual framings – characters looking directly into camera, glass cell reflections.
  • Howard Shore's score and needle drops.
  • Cannibal culture kicked off by this film.
  • 'Quid pro quo' entering the zeitgeist.
  • Night goggles. The glass instead of bars. Double endings.
  • The William Goldman editing story.
What aged the worst?
  • The sequels/prequels: Hannibal (Jodie refused the script where Clarice and Lecter become lovers on LSD), Red Dragon remaking 'Manhunter' with older Hopkins.
  • Criminal profiling as a concept – 'It turns out that might not work' / 'pseudoscience.'
  • Trump repeatedly referencing Hannibal Lecter during the 2024 presidential campaign.
  • Opening credit graphics/fonts (early 90s aesthetic).
Most cinematic shot

The guard (Lt. Boyle) hung up like an angel/butterfly – inspired by painter Francis Bacon.

Best needle drop
  • 'Goodbye Horses' by Q Lazarus (the tuck dance).
  • 'American Girl' by Tom Petty (Catherine Martin's kidnapping).
  • 'Hip Priest' by The Fall (going into the basement).
Weak link of the movie
  • Mallory: The puzzle/anagram elements are 'comparatively clunky' (Hester Moffett = The Rest of Me, Lewis Friend = Iron Sulfide).
  • Bill and Sean: Jack Crawford – picked someone barely in the top quarter of her class for the most dangerous criminal in America; never realized the first victim knew Buffalo Bill; stormed the wrong house; Clarice wandered into a dungeon alone.
The hottest take award
  • Sean: Hopkins's Oscar is 'fraudulent' – should have been nominated in Supporting Actor, not Best Actor.
  • CR: 'Lecter's an incredible therapist' – three sessions, completely solves childhood trauma.
  • Mallory: Catherine Martin should have died because of what she did to Precious (the dog).
  • Bill: This isn't Hopkins's greatest performance – The Father is better.
Casting what-ifs
  • Gene Hackman was going to direct and play Lecter or Crawford. His daughter told him not to do it.
  • Sean Connery was Demme's choice for Lecter; he turned it down.
  • Michelle Pfeiffer was Demme's choice for Clarice; she turned it down over subject matter.
  • Meg Ryan turned it down because it was too gruesome. Molly Ringwald auditioned.
  • Ed Harris turned down Jack Crawford because he 'didn't find the role interesting.'
Over-acting award
  • Hopkins 'dials it up a couple of times with eyebrows.'
  • Brooke Smith screaming from the pit (though justified).
Best "that guy"
  • Ted Levine / Buffalo Bill (easy winner).
  • Other candidates: Anthony Heald (Dr. Chilton), Charles Napier (Lt. Boyle), Frankie Faison (Barney), Stuart Rudin (Miggs), Dan Butler (Bulldog from Frasier).
Re-casting couch

Shot mostly in Pittsburgh despite being set in Baltimore (Mallory finds this 'enraging').

Half-assed (internet) research
  • Lecter mask created by Ed Cubberly from New Jersey (NHL goalie mask maker).
  • Buffalo Bill's house in Perryopolis, PA sold for $195K in 2016.
  • Brooke Smith gained 25 lbs; the prop lady lotion story.
  • Lt. Boyle's body display inspired by Francis Bacon.
  • Swallowing your own tongue is physically impossible – Miggs must have bitten it off and choked.
Apex Mountain
  • Jonathan Demme: Yes (over 'Philadelphia').
  • Anthony Hopkins: Yes.
  • Serial killer movies: Yes (competition: Seven, 'Zodiac').
  • Q Lazarus: Definitely.
  • Ted Levine: Definitely.
  • Night goggles: This or 'Jurassic Park'.
  • The tuck dance: Definitely.
Cruise or Hanks?
Cruise wins

Cruise for Lecter. Sean: 'Cruise can play every male part in this movie convincingly.' Mallory: Hanks would be a great Crawford.

Picking nits
  • Chilton has 600 rules for visiting Lecter, then leaves a pen behind.
  • Most notorious criminal in America, no cameras, only two guards for the escape.
  • Lecter fits perfectly into the guard's clothes and face.
  • The elaborate butterfly display of Lt. Boyle would have taken ages with no one checking.
  • Paramedics can't tell the 'victim' in the ambulance is healthy with someone else's face.
  • Nobody spots a moth cocoon in 5 victims' throats until Clarice.
(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • Was Miggs his first name or last name?
  • How did Buffalo Bill get into Q Lazarus and The Fall?
  • What did Lecter say to Miggs to make him kill himself?
  • Did Catherine Martin keep Precious?
  • What did Lecter pair Chilton with when he had his 'friend for dinner'?
What memorabilia would you want (or not want!) from the movie?
  • Winner: The lotion and basket combo.
  • Also discussed: The Lecter mask(s), night goggles, the drawing of Clarice holding the lamb.
Best (or worst!) life lessons from the movie

Never help somebody move furniture – don't help a creepy guy move stuff into a van.

Best double feature for this movie
  • Bill: 'Manhunter'.
  • Sean: 'Zodiac'.
Who won the movie?

All four agree: Anthony Hopkins. It made him an iconic character and huge bankable actor. Foster had already won an Oscar.

Producer review

Craig called it 'the most complete movie I had ever seen' when he first watched it in high school. Praised it as a psychological thriller rather than gore-based horror.