October 08, 2024

'Poltergeist'

They're heeeeeere. The Ringer's Bill Simmons and Van Lathan run to the light to rewatch the 1982 classic, 'Poltergeist' – starring JoBeth Williams and Craig T. Nelson, directed by Tobe Hooper, and produced by Steven Spielberg.

Movie poster

Cast

JoBeth Williams as Diane Freeling

Craig T. Nelson as Steve Freeling

Zelda Rubinstein as Tangina Barrons

Directed by: Tobe Hooper

Written by: Steven Spielberg

Music by: Jerry Goldsmith

Notes

  • The 'Poltergeist' Curse: both child actresses died young – Dominique Dunne was killed by her boyfriend, Heather O'Rourke died at 12 during 'Poltergeist' 3. The boy playing Robbie was actually strangled by a malfunctioning clown prop.
  • E.T. and 'Poltergeist' came out one week apart in 1982. E.T. was the biggest movie of the year; 'Poltergeist' was the biggest horror movie. Spielberg was on the covers of Time and Newsweek.
  • The Spielberg/Hooper directing controversy: the DGA got involved. Spielberg said Hooper 'isn't a take-charge sort of guy.' Frank Marshall said Spielberg designed every storyboard and was on set every day except three.
  • Drew Barrymore was considered for Carol Anne but was cast as Gertie in E.T. instead – a career-defining fork in the road.
  • Bill's hottest take: Zelda Rubinstein might be perfectly cast because she looks like a medium, but she might not be a very good actress. Wonders what happens with Viola Davis or Sally Field in the role.
  • The film earned 3 Oscar nominations but lost all three to E.T. – Spielberg competing against himself.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

Poltergeist is an effective thriller, not so much because of the special effects, as because Hooper and Spielberg have tried to see the movie's strange events through the eyes of the family members.

Ebert praised it for seeing strange events through the eyes of the family rather than letting special effects overwhelm the cast.

Most re-watchable scene

The final 15 minutes – clown attack, JoBeth Williams thrown up the wall, the pool with skeletons, 'You son of a bitch, you left the bodies and you only moved the headstones'

The most 1982 thing about this movie
  • Atari 2600 with controllers sitting on top of the TV
  • Snow/static on the TV
  • Giant Sony box TVs with dials on the side
What aged the best?
  • Spielberg's technique of establishing a normal family for 15 minutes so the horror resonates
  • The mom smoking a joint in bed
  • Evil late-70s/early-80s white businessman villain archetype
What aged the worst?
  • The catcalling of the teenage daughter by construction workers, and the mom watching and laughing
  • The face-melting special effects look very 1982
  • The family not being properly scared when chairs slide across the kitchen
Most cinematic shot
  • The skeletons popping up in the swimming pool
  • The reveal that the new housing phase is being built on graves
Weak link of the movie

The musical score by Jerry Goldsmith – too happy/upbeat, feels like the E.T. score rather than a horror film score

The hottest take award
  • Bill: Zelda Rubinstein might not be a very good actress – wonders what happens with an awesome actress in that role
  • Van: the ghost world has reverse racial dynamics – ghosts are always messing with white people
Casting what-ifs
  • Steven Spielberg wanted Stephen King to co-write the screenplay; King said no
  • Drew Barrymore was considered for Carol Anne but was cast as Gertie in E.T. instead
  • Shirley MacLaine reportedly turned down a starring role
Best "that guy"

Zelda Rubinstein as Tangina – she's 'the lady from Poltergeist,' the definition of a That Guy

Apex Mountain
  • Steven Spielberg – yes, Raiders in '81 then E.T. + Poltergeist a week apart in '82
  • JoBeth Williams – yes
  • Creepy clowns in a bedroom – yes
  • Family ghost movies – yes
  • Cursed real-life movies – yes, the most cursed movie ever
Cruise or Hanks?
Hanks wins

Easiest Hanks in a while – Craig T. Nelson's suburban everyman dad is pure Hanks territory

Picking nits
  • Craig T. Nelson leaving for poker night after spirits are supposedly cleared, leaving his family alone
  • The family taking 4-5 days to actually leave after being told 'the house is clean'
Sequel, prequel, prestige TV or untouchable?

A prestige TV version with different houses built over graveyards, 5-6 episodes Mike Flanagan style

(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • Is JoBeth Williams' character the stepmom of the oldest daughter?
  • How many YouTube views would the paranormal crew's video footage get? North of 50 million.
What memorabilia would you want (or not want!) from the movie?
  • The TV from the movie
  • The Darth Vader clock/head from Robbie's room
Best (or worst!) life lessons from the movie

When weird scary shit starts happening in your house, get out. Don't be a hero. Just leave.

Best double feature for this movie

E.T. first, then Poltergeist – do the fun heartwarming version then go dark

Who won the movie?

JoBeth Williams – she should have gotten more credit but was overshadowed by the Summer of Spielberg

Producer review

Craig loved it despite not being a horror guy, called it 'Spielberg mixed with horror' and said Spielberg clearly directed this movie based on watching it