December 11, 2023

'The Pelican Brief'

Everyone Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, Sean Fennessey, and Amanda Dobbins have told about this podcast is dead. But that doesn't stop them from rewatching the 1993 American legal thriller 'The Pelican Brief,' starring Julia Roberts and Denzel Washington. The film is based on the 1992 novel by John Grisham and directed by Alan J. Pakula.

Movie poster

Cast

Julia Roberts as Darby Shaw

Denzel Washington as Gray Grantham

Sam Shepard as Thomas Callahan

Stanley Tucci as Khamel

Tony Goldwyn as Fletcher Cole

John Lithgow as Smith Keen

John Heard as Gavin Verheek

Anthony Heald as Markinson

William Atherton as Bob Gminski

Directed by: Alan J. Pakula

Written by: Alan J. Pakula

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

Ordinary novels are easier to film than great ones, because the director doesn't have to waste time on details that the novelist has already established.
  • Wrote that a good director can 'create the illusion of meaning'.
  • Did a 'drive-by shooting' of Grisham, saying his plots are average and 'his novels exist to be filmed'.
Most re-watchable scene
  • The two judge murders (nursing home and gay movie theater).
  • Sam Shepard's car bomb scene.
  • The Riverwalk assassination sequence.
What aged the best?
  • Sam Shepard's appeal as an actor and a presence.
  • Newspapers as a cool movie device; New Orleans as a filming location.
  • Tony Goldwyn playing a scumbag.
What aged the worst?
  • The movie being 141 minutes (3 minutes longer than All the President's Men).
  • Floppy disks, old computers, porn theaters as plot devices.
  • The 8-minute opening with pelican footage before anything happens.
Weak link of the movie
  • Stanley Tucci's assassin dying without explanation of who killed him or why.
  • Darby's 'I'm scared' whispering voice for most of the movie after the car bomb.
The hottest take award
  • Julia Roberts is wildly miscast – the movie is unquestionably better with Sandra Bullock.
  • Victor Matisse could only afford two assassins despite being one of the richest men in the country.
Casting what-ifs
  • Grisham wrote Darby Shaw thinking of Julia Roberts specifically.
  • Discussion of whether this would have been better as a 1970s film with Robert Redford and Jessica Lange.
Over-acting award
  • Actually an 'underacting award' – both Julia Roberts and Denzel underplay the material.
  • Julia's car bomb reaction scene cited as the notable exception.
Best "that guy"
  • Anthony Heald wins automatically.
  • James Sikking (Hill Street Blues) and William Atherton.
Re-casting couch
  • 2023 version: Zendaya as Darby Shaw.
  • Gender-swapped: Zendaya as reporter, Tom Holland as law student; Adam Driver as Gray Grantham.
Half-assed (internet) research
  • Budget $45 million, made $193 million.
  • Julia Roberts presented Denzel his Best Actor Oscar the year after she won Best Actress.
  • Pakula died tragically when a pipe went through his windshield on the highway.
Apex Mountain
  • Tulane University and John Grisham (selling movie ideas before books are published).
  • Denzel: not yet, 'Training Day' is apex; Julia: still 'Pretty Woman' at this point.
Picking nits
  • Poor protection for Supreme Court justices – one caretaker, easy break-in.
  • Julia and Denzel don't appear on screen together until the 68-minute mark.
(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • Is Gray Grantham dating, married, divorced, asexual, or gay?
  • Could Sam Shepard have been one of the biggest movie stars in the world?
Best double feature for this movie
  • The Firm (bang them out together, long evening).
  • The Parallax View (Pakula's earlier paranoid thriller).
What memorabilia would you want (or not want!) from the movie?
  • The original Pelican brief document (the prop).
  • Denzel's Howard University T-shirt.
Best (or worst!) life lessons from the movie

If you find out about a giant government conspiracy, just keep it to yourself.

Who won the movie?

Amanda: Sam Shepard; Sean: Denzel Washington – crosses from A-list to A-plus; Bill: John Grisham.

Producer review

Craig Horlbeck.