Would this movie be better with...?

This is the one "evergreen" category that went through the most radical changes throughout the show's run. It started as a simple question, suggested by one of the fans: "Would this movie be better with Danny Trejo?", in the 'Face/Off' episode. In 'Midnight Run', the list of actors grew to include Michael K. Williams and Steve Buscemi.

Then, The New Categories Selection Show episode removed Michael K. Williams, and added Kathryn Hahn, Samuel L. Jackson, J.T. Walsh, Philip Baker Hall, and the character Wayne Jenkins from the TV show 'We Own This City', played by Jon Bernthal. Once that character was introduced, Chris Ryan started performing a legendary impression of Wayne Jenkins appearing in the movie, complete with his trademark "God damn!" and "You're going away a long f*cking time, big boy" catchphrases (which first happened during the 'Cop Land' show, but really came in shape in the 'There Will Be Blood' episode).

That gave other hosts the license to perform their own impressions, both for fictional characters like Longlegs, Nel, Daniel Plainview from 'There Will Be Blood', and Fergie the Florist from 'The Town', as well as celebrities such as NFL announcers Cris Collinsworth and Mike Turico, U2 frontman Bono, NBA commentators Doris Burke and Ryan Ruocco, and many others.

The most recent preferred impression by CR seems to be the New Zealand radio DJ Zane Lowe.