November 04, 2025

'The Truman Show'

The Ringer's Bill Simmons and Chris Ryan are joined by actor Glen Powell to rewatch Jim Carrey's 1998 classic 'The Truman Show,' directed by Peter Weir and starring Laura Linney and Ed Harris.

Movie poster

Cast

Jim Carrey as Truman Burbank

Laura Linney as Meryl

Ed Harris as Christof

Noah Emmerich as Marlon

Natascha McElhone as Lauren/Sylvia

Directed by: Peter Weir

Written by: Andrew Niccol

Notes

  • Budget of $60 million, grossed $264 million.
  • Oscar noms: 3 (Ed Harris for Supporting Actor, Peter Weir for Directing, Andrew Niccol for Original Screenplay). Jim Carrey was notably snubbed for Best Actor.
  • Siskel and Ebert gave it 2 thumbs up and issued an on-air apology to Jim Carrey – after Ace Ventura they said he'd never have a movie career.
  • Peter Weir spent a year storyboarding; created backstories for all characters; hadn't made a film since Fearless (1993). Waited a year for Carrey.
  • Andrew Niccol wrote it in 1993; 16 drafts. Originally more of a dark thriller; first director attached was Brian De Palma.
  • Score by Philip Glass. The poster (by Rob Silverman) cost $75K.
  • Filmed Truman's house at a Florida residence that was Matt Gaetz's childhood home.
  • Glenn Powell's first Rewatchables appearance.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

It brings into focus the new values that technology is forcing on humanity.

Ebert gave it 4 stars. Siskel and Ebert issued an on-air apology to Jim Carrey after having said he'd never have a career.

Most re-watchable scene
  • Glenn: Truman putting it all together – going through the revolving door, 'he's starting to see the ones and zeros.' 'The wish fulfillment of the whole movie.'
  • CR: Truman going through the revolving door and walking into the black doorway.
  • Bill: The ending when he hits the wall – 'I've seen this movie multiple times and it still takes me back.' Also: the opening with Christof's interview, Truman's flashback to Lauren in high school.
The most 1998 thing about this movie
  • Glenn: Travel agents; reality television being a novel idea – 'in 1998 this would have seemed incredibly far-fetched and now it seems like Oh yeah, is there a Truman Show on Channel 236?'
  • Bill: Young Paul Giamatti – 'he had this whole that guy run in the 90s before he became Paul Giamatti.'
What aged the best?
  • Bill: Product placement satire; adults playing high school kids in flashbacks believably; no cats in Seahaven (only dogs); T-Rex '20th Century Boy' as a 1950s cover; the Philip Glass score.
  • Glenn: The poster; Laura Linney's deliberately bad acting during product placement scenes.
  • CR: The reality TV prediction – predicted Survivor/Big Brother two years early.
What aged the worst?
  • Glenn: CGI of the bubble/dome; cutbacks to real world could have explored ethical/legal entanglements more.
  • Craig: The Matt Gaetz connection to the filming location.
Most cinematic shot
  • Bill: The final shot – Truman silhouetted against the painted sky.
  • Glenn: The moment he hits the wall and sees the painted clouds up close.
Weak link of the movie
  • Glenn: The dad storyline could have been better with a bigger/more empathetic actor.
  • Bill: What was actually fun about watching this show 24 hours a day?
The hottest take award
  • Glenn: The movie could have been really good with Tom Hanks – 'he represents the everyman. Jim Carrey is so over the top as a person. Hanks would represent a little bit more of an everyman realizing he represents something to the world.'
  • CR: Brian De Palma's version would have been amazing – 'more paranoid, debased psychology. Truman cutting up magazine pictures to recreate Lauren. Melanie Griffith playing Meryl.'
  • Bill: 1998 is in the running for the greatest movie year ever – rattled off 20+ categories all filled with great films ('Saving Private Ryan', Big Lebowski, 'Rounders', There's Something About Mary, 'Out of Sight', 'Enemy of the State', 'He Got Game', 'Armageddon', 'Ronin', etc.).
Casting what-ifs
  • Brian De Palma was originally attached to direct.
  • Peter Weir waited a year for Carrey (who had to make Cable Guy and Liar Liar first).
  • Originally conceived as a darker, more paranoid thriller.
Best "that guy"

Young Paul Giamatti – 'bellhop in 'My Best Friend's Wedding', this whole that guy run in the 90s.' Also: Harry Shearer, Peter Krause, Holland Taylor.

Apex Mountain
  • Jim Carrey: Bill says yes. Carrey's 1994-2000 run discussed as possibly the best comedian crossover ever: Ace Ventura, The Mask, 'Dumb and Dumber', 'Batman' Forever, Cable Guy, Liar Liar, Truman Show, Man on the Moon.
  • Reality TV: Right before its actual apex.
Picking nits
  • Bill: How do they handle it when Truman goes to the bathroom? What about the extremely boring parts of his daily routine?
  • Glenn: The scale of the operation seems impossibly expensive to maintain for 35 years.
Best (or worst!) life lessons from the movie

Bill: 'Just because I'm paranoid doesn't mean people aren't out to get me.' Also: the audience immediately changes the channel after 35 years – 'What else is on?'

Best double feature for this movie
  • CR: The Matrix – both about discovering your reality is fake.
  • Glenn: The Game (Fincher, 1997).
  • Bill: Gattaca – the other Andrew Niccol film.
Who won the movie?

Glenn and Bill: Jim Carrey. 'He needed this one.'

Producer review

Craig had seen it many times. Said the movie feels ahead of its time – 'it feels like a 2015 movie in 1998.'