Rewatchables Reference

• Bill: The nightclub scene – the guys busting on Martin, buying the beers, Leslie Mann and Heigl interacting with Jason Segel, the dice move.
• Craig: The fantasy baseball draft scene where Leslie Mann walks in – 'We said no wives! Your fantasy what?... Honey, we got Matsui.'
• Juliet: Seth Rogen interacting with Maude Apatow for the first time at the breakfast table. Also Allison visiting the guys' house – Jonah Hill watching 'Wild Things' saying 'Another day at the office'.
• Also: the double date ('Why don't the two of you get into your time machine'), the Vegas mushrooms sequence, the Craig Robinson doorman scene.

• Bill: Jonah Hill – every moment he's in, he's crushing it. Craig: 'One of the best yellers in comedy history.'
• The Apatow kids (Maude and Iris) – knowing Maude becomes a legitimate actress on Euphoria makes it fascinating to rewatch.
• Ryan Seacrest's cameo making fun of himself – 'the most lovable he has ever been' (Juliet).
• Craig: Jason Segel naked after the earthquake, cupping his junk. Also Seth Rogen's Matthew Fox dig: 'You know what's interesting about Matthew Fox? Nothing.'
• The randoms who became bigger: Bill Hader, Craig Robinson, Ken Jeong, James Franco and Steve Carell cameos, Adam Scott as the nurse.

• The movie is 132 minutes – way too long. Too much Leslie Mann/Paul Rudd subplot; the second half drags (all three hosts).
• Katherine Heigl's wardrobe – 'so of that moment': flowy halter tops, too-low-and-too-wide jeans (Juliet).
• Debbie being anti-vax – 'does not play well' post-COVID (Juliet and Bill).
• Ken Jeong's doctor character – too mean (Craig). Bill: 'I didn't like his character at all.'
• They kept saying 'webpage' instead of website (Juliet).

• Bill: The fantasy baseball cheating subplot – nine minutes in the middle about whether Paul Rudd's character is cheating, with no real payoff. 'This is supposed to be about Seth Rogen and Katherine Heigl.'
• Craig: 'I think Judd fell in love with that storyline more than the original one halfway through the movie.'

• Bill: Katherine Heigl and Lindsay Lohan are the two lost superstars of the decade.
• Juliet: She should have had an abortion. 'He's a 23-year-old with zero dollars, no job, doesn't have his own home.'

• Anne Hathaway was originally cast but dropped out over childbirth footage disagreements. Juliet: 'She would have been excellent.'
• Jennifer Love Hewitt, Kate Bosworth, and Christina Aguilera reportedly auditioned.
• Mila Kunis auditioned but didn't get it – Apatow put her on 'Forgetting Sarah Marshall' instead.

• The pigtail stoner girl (Charlyne Yi) – improvising with no lines, 'she's in a different movie'.
• Ken Jeong's doctor character – too aggressive for no reason.

• Bill: Kristen Wiig – in two scenes, really funny in both, really elevates them.
• Juliet: Ryan Seacrest. Craig breaks the tie for Wiig.
• Other nominees: Bill Hader, Iris Apatow, Stormy Daniels, Craig Robinson.

• Bill: Sydney Sweeney in the Heigl role.
• Juliet: Gaten Matarazzo (from Stranger Things) as the Seth Rogen role.

• Jay Baruchel's rollercoaster reactions are all real – everyone kept throwing up during filming.
• DVD special feature where Michael Cera gets fake-fired and Bennett Miller comes in to co-direct.
• Katherine Heigl was only #14 on Maxim's Hot 100 of 2007.
• In 2014, Heigl owned eight dogs, four cats, nine horses, two donkeys, two goats, and eight chickens.

• Katherine Heigl – unanimous.
• Judd Apatow – possibly. This plus 'Superbad' within two months. Juliet thinks 40-Year-Old Virgin edges it.
• Seth Rogen – this proved he could be a leading man, then 'Superbad' two months later.
• Unplanned pregnancy movies – this is the apex (Bill).
• Fantasy sports moments in movies – possibly the most high-profile ever (Craig).

• The condom miscommunication doesn't make sense – just have a broken condom instead (all three).
• She would never stay at the bar alone without her sister or another friend (Juliet).
• Paul Rudd barely works but has a beautiful Brentwood home. Seth Rogen gets a huge apartment after working for a week (Craig).

• Can you get pink eye from farting on a pillow? Craig: 'That was a known thing in college – people called it frat eye.'
• How does Ben pay for literally anything? No one in this group is working (Juliet).

Bill: Eight episodes on Amazon – similar to Catastrophe with Rob Delaney and Sharon Horgan.

• Juliet: Alan Tudyk as Allison's boss at E!
• Bill: Joanna Kerns – the mom from Growing Pains plays Leslie Mann and Katherine Heigl's mother.

• Bill: This Is 40 – running it back with the same characters.
• Craig: 'Forgetting Sarah Marshall' – 'Give me Segel now.'
• Juliet: 'Adventureland' – many of the same people, directed by Greg Mottola.

• Craig and Juliet: 'Shimmy Shimmy Ya' by Ol' Dirty Bastard right at the start.
• Bill: 'Rock Lobster' by the B-52s when they go back to his place.

• Bill and Craig: The Larami Tuncel gas mask bong.
• Juliet: The random samurai sword that Ben owns.

Bill: Don't fall for an unemployed stoner making a Mr. Skin ripoff site.

Juliet and Bill: Seth Rogen – this movie opened the door for him as a leading man, then 'Superbad' two months later made him an acting/writing powerhouse.

• Craig gave it high marks – 'Finally, there's just a bunch of idiots watching Family Guy, smoking weed – somebody put that on screen.'
• Craig thinks the ideal length would be about 1 hour 45 minutes (currently 2 hours 12 minutes).