March 28, 2023

'Cape Fear'

The Ringer's Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, and Sean Fennessey rewatch Martin Scorsese's 'Cape Fear,' starring Robert De Niro, Jessica Lange, and Juliette Lewis.

Movie poster

Cast

Robert De Niro as Max Cady

Nick Nolte as Sam Bowden

Jessica Lange as Lee Bowden

Juliette Lewis as Danielle Bowden

Joe Don Baker as Claude Kersek

Illeana Douglas as Lori Davis

Robert Mitchum as Cameo (from original film)

Gregory Peck as Cameo (from original film)

Martin Balsam as Cameo (from original film)

Fred Thompson as Supporting role

Directed by: Martin Scorsese

Written by: Wesley Strick

Cinematography by: Freddie Francis

Music by: Bernard Herrmann, Elmer Bernstein

Notes

  • Budget: $35 million. Domestic gross: $182.3 million.
  • 7th Scorsese-De Niro collaboration. Remake of the 1962 film based on the novel 'The Executioners.'
  • The famous Spielberg/Scorsese trade: Spielberg gave Scorsese 'Cape Fear', Scorsese gave Spielberg Schindler's List.
  • De Niro nominated for Best Actor (lost to Hopkins for Silence of the Lambs). Juliette Lewis nominated for Best Supporting Actress.
  • Same year as Silence of the Lambs (1991); both had face-biting scenes and over-the-top dark villains.
  • The Simpsons 'Cape Feare' episode is considered one of the greatest Simpsons episodes.
  • Shot in 1:2.39 widescreen, the first time Scorsese used that ratio.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

Cape Fear is impressive moviemaking, showing that Scorsese is a master of traditional Hollywood genre.

Questioned whether it was a 'good omen' – not an advance from the man who made 'Taxi Driver', Raging Bull, and 'Goodfellas'.

Most re-watchable scene
  • Bill: Max Cady leaving prison (opening scene with tattoos, 'Already read them').
  • Bill's favorite: Max fending off three hitmen (bike chain fight).
  • Chris: The whole night waiting for Cady with the teddy bear / Joe Don Baker getting killed.
  • Sean: Max Cady calling Danielle while hanging upside down.
  • The Juliette Lewis playhouse scene singled out as the most riveting scene in the movie.
What aged the best?
  • De Niro's laughing in the movie theater (Problem Child scene).
  • Jessica Lange's character/performance at the perfect age for the role.
  • The Simpsons 'Cape Feare' episode (one of the 5-6 best Simpsons episodes ever).
  • Juliette Lewis's career renaissance (Yellowjackets).
  • Bernard Herrmann's score (rearranged by Elmer Bernstein).
  • Max's tattoo reveals (vegetable ink, stuck on De Niro for months).
  • De Niro paid $5K to mess up his teeth, $20K to fix them.
Best needle drop

De Niro silhouetted against 4th of July fireworks with the Bernard Herrmann score coming in hard (Brian De Palma/'Blow Out' homage).

Weak link of the movie
  • Illeana Douglas's character not testifying (the plot logic of police not pursuing Cady despite the assault).
  • The overall handling of law enforcement response to Cady's crimes.
What aged the worst?
  • The De Niro/Illeana Douglas assault scene – horrible to watch.
  • The Juliette Lewis auditorium scene – her age makes it uncomfortable.
  • Sam's relationship with his daughter (grabbing her face, 'put some clothes on').
  • The special effects of the boat/water in the climax – 'really bad'.
The hottest take award
  • Chris: Max Cady was actually a great marriage counselor – unorthodox methods but brought Lee and Sam back together.
  • Bill: De Niro is indisputably the greatest maniac actor ever (Travis Bickle, Rupert Pupkin, Max Cady, Jimmy Conway).
Casting what-ifs
  • Scorsese wanted Harrison Ford as Sam; Ford only wanted to play Max Cady.
  • Spielberg wanted Bill Murray as Cady.
  • ~500 actresses auditioned for Danielle including Reese Witherspoon and Drew Barrymore (both 15).
  • Diane Keaton was up for the wife role.
Over-acting award
  • Jessica Lange: 'Don't you call me lady!'; constant smoking and face-touching; screaming about the dog death.
  • They suggest adding 'Lee Bowden' to the overacting award name.
Best "that guy"
  • Joe Don Baker.
  • Gregory Peck (playing a 'shit heel lawyer' while known as Atticus Finch).
  • Robert Mitchum.
Re-casting couch
  • Ryan Gosling as Sam, Emma Stone as Lee, Jon Bernthal as Max Cady.
  • All-Black cast: Sterling K. Brown and Regina King as the couple; Jamie Foxx or Yahya Abdul-Mateen II as Max Cady.
Half-assed (internet) research
  • Spielberg gave Scorsese 'Cape Fear'; Scorsese gave Spielberg Schindler's List.
  • De Niro's tattoos used vegetable ink; he paid $5K to damage his teeth, $20K to fix them.
  • De Niro researched sexual predator crimes; suggested the face-biting scene.
  • The climax filmed in a 90-foot water tank, took a month to shoot.
  • Film inspired pro wrestler Dan Spivey's character 'Waylon Mercy' and later Bray Wyatt.
  • A book in Cady's cell is a fake book from a 1989 'Miami Vice' episode – most obscure Easter egg.
Apex Mountain
  • De Niro: As a box office star, possibly yes ('Goodfellas'/'Cape Fear' era).
  • Nolte: No – 1970s or 48 Hours era.
  • Juliette Lewis: No – Natural Born Killers.
  • Fred Thompson: Yes (Hunt for Red October, 'Days of Thunder', 'Die Hard 2', 'Cape Fear' in 18 months).
  • 'Cape Fear' (the place): Yes.
Picking nits
  • Double murder in the house and they don't call the cops; instead flee to 'Cape Fear'.
  • Max Cady hanging under the car for three hours on the way to 'Cape Fear'.
  • Joe Don Baker not noticing the maid had been replaced/killed.
  • Sam could have legally shot Cady for trespassing instead of hiring hitmen.
  • Juliette Lewis's voiceover: 'We never talked about Max Cady again' – impossible.
(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • Was Lee kind of into Max Cady on the boat?
  • Is this one of the top 5 greatest De Niro death scenes? (Heat, 'Taxi Driver', Jackie Brown, 'Cape Fear').
What memorabilia would you want (or not want!) from the movie?
  • Bill: De Niro's bikini lighter.
  • Chris: Sam's Mustang or Sam's seersucker suit.
Best (or worst!) life lessons from the movie
  • Bill: Don't bury evidence when representing a client.
  • Chris: Leave town; get the fuck out.
  • Sean: 'I am as large as God. God is as small as I.' – read your scripture.
Best double feature for this movie
  • Chris: The original 1962 'Cape Fear'.
  • Sean: Vertigo (because of the overt Hitchcock homages).
Who won the movie?

Robert De Niro / Max Cady – unanimous.