January 23, 2023

'Big'

Bill, Mal, and Van get their wish granted and rewatch 'Big,' starring Tom Hanks, Elizabeth Perkins, and Robert Loggia.

Movie poster

Cast

Tom Hanks as Josh Baskin (adult)

David Moscow as Josh Baskin (young)

Elizabeth Perkins as Susan Lawrence

Robert Loggia as MacMillan

John Heard as Paul

Jared Rushton as Billy Kopecki

Mercedes Ruehl as Mrs. Baskin

Jon Lovitz as Scotty Brennen

Directed by: Penny Marshall

Written by: Gary Ross, Anne Spielberg

Music by: Howard Shore

Notes

  • Budget: $18 million. Domestic gross: $151.7 million. Fourth biggest movie of 1988.
  • Penny Marshall was the first female director to direct a $100M+ grossing film.
  • Fourth body switch movie released in a span of a year (after Like Father Like Son, Vice Versa, 18 Again).
  • Hanks nominated for Best Actor Oscar but lost to Dustin Hoffman ('Rain Man'). Bill argues Hanks should have won.
  • Also nominated for Best Original Screenplay (Gary Ross & Anne Spielberg).
  • Penny Marshall quote (1989): 'It's a little more acceptable that a 13-year-old boy has an experience with a woman. The other way it's impossible. It's Polanskiville.'
  • Extensively discussed: the problematic nature of the Susan/Josh relationship when viewed through a modern lens.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

Big is a tender, soft-hearted and cheerful movie, well-directed by Penny Marshall and with a screenplay that has a lot of fun with simple, basic situations.
  • Compared it unfavorably to Vice Versa.
  • Bill estimates 2.5 stars and notes Ebert may have missed on this one.
Most re-watchable scene
  • FAO Schwarz piano/chopsticks scene – clear winner.
  • Also: Josh wakes up as an adult, the gross hotel room, the 'I don't get it' boardroom scene.
  • The company cocktail party, Josh making his wish at the Zoltar machine, the trampoline scene.
What aged the best?
  • The casting of young Josh (David Moscow) and Hanks – realistic that kid grew up into Hanks.
  • Hanks acting like a kid (the nodding, mannerisms).
  • Susan as ruthless 1980s career woman.
  • Josh's dream apartment.
  • Josh and Billy's best friendship bond.
Best needle drop
  • 'Hot in the City' by Billy Idol (limo scene after the cocktail party).
  • Van: 'Forget Me Nots' by Patrice Rushen during the trampoline scene.
Weak link of the movie
  • The kidnapping subplot – glossed over, no tracer on the phone, unrealistic police investigation.
  • Josh's dad appears at the very beginning then completely disappears.
  • Mallory wanted more character development for Susan.
What aged the worst?
  • Susan being OK with the situation after finding out Josh is 13 (her reaction is too calm).
  • The MacMillan Toys interview/recruitment process (no vetting).
  • The text-based video games of 1988.
  • Overall: 'dating children aged pretty badly'.
Casting what-ifs
  • Robert De Niro was originally attached (how the movie got greenlit).
  • Steven Spielberg considered directing it with Harrison Ford.
  • Dennis Quaid turned it down to do Everybody's All American.
  • Jared Rushton read with Richard Dreyfuss and Sean Penn for the Josh role.
  • John Travolta really wanted the part but was in a career slump.
Over-acting award

John Heard as Paul at the cocktail party – suddenly more drunk than anyone in history at a corporate cocktail party.

Best "that guy"
  • James Eckhouse (the dad from Beverly Hills 90210) – also appeared in 'Cocktail' the same year.
  • Also: the toothless hotel clerk, Josh's secretary.
Half-assed (internet) research
  • Zoltar Speaks machine was invented for this movie, since copyrighted and now available for purchase.
  • David Moscow (young Josh) was later engaged to Kerry Washington.
  • Josh's baby sister has no credits and remains a mystery.
  • The Shimmy Shimmy Cocoa Bop was Hanks's idea from his son's summer camp.
  • The Yankee game was July 1987 (Tim Stoddard pitched to Angel Salazar).
  • They built a larger walking piano for the movie that stayed at FAO Schwarz.
Apex Mountain
  • 1980s Tom Hanks: Bill argues three Tom Hanks eras (80s, 90s starting with League of Their Own, 21st century).
  • Elizabeth Perkins: Absolutely.
  • Robert Loggia: Debatable.
  • Body switch movies: Yes.
  • Zoltar machine: Yes.
Picking nits
  • The carnival is completely gone by 7:30 AM the next morning.
  • Josh immediately gets a job (unrealistic for a 13-year-old).
  • Susan stays interested after seeing Josh's insane apartment.
  • Billy's parents let him go to NYC every day.
  • No explanation for how Josh gets an apartment in Soho.
  • Sports bigamy: Yankees AND Mets stuff in Billy's room.
Sequel, prequel, prestige TV or untouchable?
  • Sequel ('Bigger'): Mallory pitches Josh at 30 in existential crisis, never able to recapture his 13-year-old success.
  • A Zoltar anthology series.
(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • What happened to Josh's apartment after he left?
  • Does Susan face criminal charges?
  • What happened to adult Josh (missing person)?
  • Has anyone else ever used the Zoltar machine?
  • Where is Josh's dad?
  • Could Josh reintegrate into normal kid life?
What memorabilia would you want (or not want!) from the movie?
  • The FAO Schwarz walking piano (top pick).
  • Zoltar Speaks machine (close second).
Best (or worst!) life lessons from the movie
  • If your boyfriend tells you he's actually 13 years old, don't play with his ear as you say goodbye – immediately treat him like your nephew.
  • You start dressing better once you get some ass.
Who won the movie?
  • Tom Hanks, without question.
  • Van adds: 'Really, we won' (the audience).
  • Outside of Hanks: Penny Marshall or the screenplay.