April 02, 2024

'Shot Caller'

The Ringer's Bill Simmons and Chris Ryan are forced to become warriors or victims after rewatching the 2017 crime thriller 'Shot Caller,' starring Nikolaj Coster-Waldau, Lake Bell, and Jon Bernthal.

Movie poster

Cast

Nikolaj Coster-Waldau as Jacob / Money

Jon Bernthal as Shotgun

Holt McCallany as The Beast

Jeffrey Donovan as Bottles

Lake Bell as Kate

Omari Hardwick as Kutcher

Benjamin Bratt as Herman

Evan Jones as Chopper

Emory Cohen as Howie

Directed by: Ric Roman Waugh

Written by: Ric Roman Waugh

Notes

  • $3.4 million box office. Relativity Media acquired US rights for $3M then went bankrupt in 2015, delaying release by two years during Coster-Waldau's peak Game of Thrones fame.
  • Rick Roman Waugh filmed Felon (with Val Kilmer) at the same prison before making 'Shot Caller' – 'the tester for the bigger budget of the same version of the movie.'
  • Waugh compared the film's structure to The Deer Hunter.
  • Coster-Waldau is Danish, and his accent 'breaks a little bit' in a couple scenes.
  • Bill ranks it as his 6th favorite prison movie: Shawshank (top), Cool Hand Luke & 'Bad Boys' (2nd), Jericho Mile & Longest Yard & 'Shot Caller' (3rd).
  • Available on Netflix. Part of 'Rock Bottom Month' on The Rewatchables.

Categories

Most re-watchable scene
  • Bill: The prison riot – the preparation (passing shanks, digging up contraband) and the chaos that follows.
  • CR: Money kills the Beast – 'so visually overwhelming, him being covered in blood in these white shorts.' Runner-up: Money's welcome-home party.
  • Craig: The final showdown in the desert cage cells.
  • Also discussed: Bottles' voiceover speech ('The fact is we all started out as someone's little angel...'), Bernthal's extended death scene ('I'm no punk').
What aged the best?
  • CR: 'When getting caught is part of the plan' trope – Money deliberately getting put back in prison.
  • Bill: The concept of a 'shot caller' as a term; the outdoor box cage cells in the desert; bulletproof vest fake-out + prepaid cell phones; Lake Bell; the horseshoe mustache; Jon Bernthal (especially pre-We Own This City).
  • The letter to his son: 'Make your mark on this world, be your mother's protector.'
What aged the worst?
  • Coster-Waldau's accent slipping in a couple scenes.
  • The terrible soccer scene.
  • The parole board scene – obviously corrupt guard vouches for Money despite 20 new tattoos and a horseshoe mustache.
  • Sexual assault as a prison movie staple.
Weak link of the movie
  • Bill: Jacob becomes a gang banger 'a whiff too fast'; his decision to completely cut ties with family felt overly harsh.
  • CR: The gun deal dynamics between Shotgun, Herman, and the Mexican gangs get 'convoluted or compressed.' The actual payoff/shootout 'doesn't 100% work.'
Over-acting award
  • Omari Hardwick in the car scene with Benjamin Bratt, doing the flashback monologue about getting shot.
  • Also: Bernthal's extended death scene.
Best "that guy"

Evan Jones (Chopper) – credits include Jarhead, 8 Mile, 'Den of Thieves': 'I always have to look him up.'

The hottest take award
  • CR: If the movie were told linearly instead of dual-timeline, it would maximize the 'rock bottom' effect. Waugh compared it to The Deer Hunter's structure.
  • Craig counters: the non-linear opening is 'grabbier' and prevents clicking away during 15 minutes of stockbroker life.
Casting what-ifs
  • Adam Driver was the consensus winner for hypothetical recast as Money.
  • Gerard Butler or Pablo Schreiber also discussed (both worked with Waugh later).
  • Michael Mann as director – the film has heavy Mann influences (LA driving scenes evoke 'Collateral').
Cruise or Hanks?
Cruise wins

Unanimous Cruise. Bill: 'This is the Cruise movie I always wanted. He basically gave it to us in 'Collateral'.' Cruise would have done the bodybuilding, practiced the shanking, done the slicked-back hair. 'Hanks has no chance.'

Half-assed (internet) research
  • Bernthal's character (Pen One / Public Enemy Number One) is a real white street gang from Orange County.
  • The Beast was loosely based on white supremacist Steven Single.
  • Prison hierarchy: Wood -> Pen One -> Nazi Low Riders -> Aryan Brotherhood (top).
  • Books on Money's prison bookshelf: The Book of Five Rings, The Art of War, The Bible, Nietzsche, The Prince, For Whom the Bell Tolls.
Apex Mountain
  • CR: Uber – 'If Jacob had Uber that night, none of this happens.'
  • Coster-Waldau: Around this time, between Thrones seasons 7 and 8.
  • Aryan Brotherhood: 'Have they ever been commemorated like this cinematically?'
Picking nits
  • Bill: No cafeteria scene – 'It's a fucking staple.'
  • Craig: No prison basketball scene showing Jacob's character arc.
  • CR: Redwood's beef with the guard is referenced but never explained; the gun deal logistics get muddled.
  • Bill: Jacob blows a 0.1 – 'Just hold off an hour and do the police station blood test.'
Sequel, prequel, prestige TV or untouchable?
  • CR: A series would allow more family content and detail on the gun deal.
  • Bill: If made three years later, Bernthal would have been the lead. Proposes a 'Bernthal Rating' for action movies: 'How many guys could Jon Bernthal have played?' This movie has a rating of 4.5.
(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • Why did they shoot at Money at the house party?
  • How do you learn to quick-stab in prison?
  • Would the shot caller really have this much control?
Best (or worst!) life lessons from the movie
  • Don't drive drunk.
  • 'If you're getting thrown in with the big boys, you got 24 hours to prove you're not going to be a victim. Warriors or victims.'
Best double feature for this movie
  • Bill: Jericho Mile + 'Shot Caller'.
  • CR: 'Den of Thieves' + 'Shot Caller'.
Who won the movie?

CR: Rick Roman Waugh – 'He goes on to write 'Den of Thieves', he's kind of created this subgenre... contemporary LA crime thriller.'

Producer review
  • Craig confirmed with his father (a lieutenant for 30 years) that vehicular manslaughter convicts really do get housed with violent criminals.
  • Three suggestions to take it from 'an 8 to a 10': a cool heist scene, more pre-prison character development, and a prison basketball scene.