'Panic Room'
The Ringer's Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, and Sean Fennessey recap the Will Smith-Chris Rock incident from last night's Academy Awards before cutting the phone lines and locking themselves in a concrete box to revisit David Fincher's 'Panic Room,' starring Jodie Foster, Kristen Stewart, Forest Whitaker, and Jared Leto.

Cast
Jodie Foster as Meg Altman
Forest Whitaker as Burnham
Jared Leto as Junior
Dwight Yoakam as Raoul
Kristen Stewart as Sarah
Directed by: David Fincher
Written by: David Koepp
Cinematography by: Conrad Hall
Notes
- Nicole Kidman was originally cast but aggravated a knee injury from Moulin Rouge two weeks into filming. She went on to make The Hours and win the Oscar.
- Jodie Foster was available because her directing project 'Flora Plum' shut down when Russell Crowe got injured.
- Foster became pregnant during filming, forcing another shutdown; the whole production took about two years.
- Fincher originally wanted Foster for The Game (she was considered for the Sean Penn role).
- The role of Raoul was originally offered to Maynard James Keenan, lead singer of Tool.
- Hayden Panettiere was originally cast in the Kristen Stewart role.
- Kristen Stewart grew more than three inches during filming.
- Darius Khondji (cinematographer of 'Se7en') started as DP but quit/was fired six weeks in; Conrad Hall replaced him.
- The script sold for $4 million, a record at the time. Koepp was inspired by 2000 news coverage about panic rooms.
- $48 million budget, grossed $197 million worldwide. Somehow Jodie Foster's biggest grossing movie as the main star.
- Fincher saw it as a cross between Rear Window and Straw Dogs.
- The four-story brownstone set was built in 15 weeks for $6 million at Raleigh Studios in Hollywood.
- Fincher innovated using cameras without operators, pre-visualizing shots digitally. He showed this to Soderbergh, who warned it would drive him insane – and was right.
- This was the first Fincher movie where the audience knows everything as it happens in real time.
- Forest Whitaker was offered the script to direct but declined; he wanted to act in it instead.
- The episode was taped the day after the 2022 Oscars (Will Smith / Chris Rock slap).
Categories
Quote from Rog's review:
“There are moments when I want to shout advice at the screen, but just as often the characters are ahead of me.”
- Ebert called Foster 'spellbinding.'
- The hosts questioned why he didn't give it 3.5 stars.
- The robbers showing up – discovering there are people in the house, the 'business days' exchange.
- Jodie getting her phone – the slow-motion sequence searching under the covers.
- Leto accidentally reveals how much money is really in the safe.
- The switcheroo – getting two criminals into the panic room while the daughter is having a diabetic seizure.
- Chris: The propane tank / gas scene – running propane into the panic room and the explosion.
- The opening title sequence / graphics showing New York buildings.
- Jared Leto's performance – his cornrows, and especially his death scene.
- How the diabetes subplot is handled – subtle, no heavy-handed exposition.
- Kristen Stewart's performance as a child actor.
- Dwight Yoakam as Raoul.
- The propane gas scene – Foster would realistically blow up in the enclosed space.
- The husband character gets overly punished – absolutely destroyed physically just for leaving his wife.
- 'I can't go to prison, man, I'm not built for that shit' – hackiest moment.
- The cops/emergency services scenes – 911 puts her on hold; police don't press hard enough.
- Nicole Kidman was originally cast as Meg Altman.
- Hayden Panettiere was originally cast in the Kristen Stewart role.
- Maynard James Keenan (Tool) was offered the role of Raoul before Dwight Yoakam.
- Paul Schulze as the cop – 'Father Phil from The Sopranos.'
- Ian Buchanan as the realtor – soap opera actor from General Hospital.
Jared Leto – 'just dials it up.'
- Stephen Altman (ex-husband): Anthony Hopkins (Bill's pick); Michael Douglas (Chris's pick).
- Raoul: Ted Levine (Bill's pick); Tom Sizemore (Sean's pick). Also discussed Henry Rollins, William Fichtner, Val Kilmer, Wes Studi.
- Kristen Stewart grew more than three inches during filming.
- The house is at 38 West 94th Street, NYC.
- The four-story brownstone set took 15 weeks and $6 million to build.
- 'Panic Room' was not on Blu-ray until its 20th anniversary week (March 2022).
- $48 million budget, $197 million worldwide gross.
- David Koepp's script sold for $4 million (a record).
- Fincher: No.
- Foster: No (Silence of the Lambs).
- Kristen Stewart: No.
- Jared Leto: No.
- Panic rooms (as a movie concept): Yes.
- Forest Whitaker: No.
- Foster doesn't get her phone when all burglars are downstairs – she has surveillance cameras.
- Multiple opportunities to open the panic room door and call 911 with cell service.
- 911 puts her on hold.
- Drunk divorced mom goes from barely able to pee to splicing phone lines and running 4.0 forty-yard dashes within an hour.
- Raoul falls down two floors of stairs and gets up fresh – Michael Myers energy.
- Whitaker wears his security company uniform to commit the robbery.
- Why not stock the panic room with diabetes supplies and a working cell phone?
Bill: If your daughter has diabetes and you have a panic room, stock it with insulin and orange juice.
- Initially exciting but ultimately no for a direct adaptation – 'this is exactly the amount of time I want to spend with these people.'
- Ideas floated: 'Panic Rooms' anthology (10 different panic rooms); same panic room across 100 years of history.
Is this the best Kristen Stewart has ever been in a movie?
- Bill: Raoul's ski mask.
- Chris: The panic room itself / the bearer bonds.
- Sean: The propane tank.
David Fincher – unanimous. '99 other people make this movie, it's totally forgettable.' Fincher elevated a B-movie premise to an A-movie through sheer craft.