April 19, 2021

'Mrs. Doubtfire'

The Ringer's Bill Simmons, Shea Serrano, and Amanda Dobbins commit a run-by fruiting as they rewatch the 1993 classic 'Mrs. Doubtfire,' starring Robin Williams, Sally Field, and Pierce Brosnan.

Movie poster

Cast

Robin Williams as Daniel Hillard / Mrs. Doubtfire

Sally Field as Miranda Hillard

Robert Prosky as Jonathan Lundy

Directed by: Chris Columbus

Notes

  • $25 million budget, made $441 million worldwide – the second highest-grossing movie of 1993 (behind only 'Jurassic Park').
  • Won the Academy Award for Best Makeup and the Golden Globe for Robin Williams.
  • Robin Williams did 15-22 takes per scene with 2-3 cameras running; never made 'Mrs. Doubtfire' 2 despite rejecting scripts from 2000-2014.
  • Robin Williams walked through San Francisco as 'Mrs. Doubtfire' and went into a sex shop to buy sex toys to see what he could get away with.
  • In 2013, it was the most shown movie on cable television (on cable 66 times that year).
  • Called 'the millennials' Kramer vs. Kramer' by Amanda.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

Tootsie grew out of real wit and insight and Mrs. Doubtfire has the values and depth of a sitcom.

Ebert: 'The film is not as amusing as the premise. There were long stretches when I had quite enough of 'Mrs. Doubtfire'.'

Most re-watchable scene
  • The pool scene / 'run by fruiting' – the single best scene in the movie (Bill and Amanda's pick).
  • The double duty restaurant dinner scene – going back and forth between identities; teeth fall in the wine glass.
  • The job interview where Robin Williams does all the voices/impressions.
  • Harvey Fierstein creating Mrs. Doubtfire's look (makeover scene).
  • The frosting/meringue scene when the apartment lady comes to check on him.
  • Sally Field opening up to 'Mrs. Doubtfire' about why she left Daniel.
  • The family watches the first 'Mrs. Doubtfire' TV show (the final speech).
What aged the best?
  • Pre-Internet San Francisco – old school SF as an awesome city (Bill's pick).
  • No sequel – they never made 'Mrs. Doubtfire' 2.
  • 'Jump Around' by House of Pain used non-ironically in the party scene – possibly the last time it was used non-ironically in a movie.
  • The grim divorced dad apartment – a classic realistic divorce trope (Amanda's pick).
What aged the worst?
  • The cross-dressing/drag comedy premise – wouldn't be made today; transphobic elements even if unintentional.
  • Sally Field's 'working mom' character being essentially the villain – early 90s trope.
  • The movie being over 2 hours – 'Mrs. Doubtfire' doesn't appear until the 37-minute mark.
  • 'Dude Looks Like a Lady' montage – the Aerosmith song lyrics have aged very poorly.
  • The bathroom scene in particular would not be done in 2021.
Casting what-ifs
  • Tim Allen was offered both the Daniel/'Mrs. Doubtfire' role AND the Pierce Brosnan role – rejected everything.
  • Blake Lively lost the role of Natalie (the youngest daughter) to Mara Wilson.
Over-acting award

Sally Field – leaning too hard into the frustrated working mom role, especially the yelling; Amanda says she had terrible material to work with.

Best "that guy"

Polly Holiday (the annoyed next-door neighbor) – played Flo on Alice; a lot of her scenes got cut.

Best "heat check" performance
  • Mara Wilson (Shea's pick).
  • Pierce Brosnan, the horny bus driver, Robert Prosky also nominated.
Re-casting couch
  • Sally Field's role – waste of her talents; Kathleen Turner suggested as alternative.
  • Amanda: 'I don't wish this role on anyone I like'.
Half-assed (internet) research
  • Robin Williams's real childhood nanny was a British lady named Lolly who was a bit like 'Mrs. Doubtfire'.
  • 'Mrs. Doubtfire' says 'dear' 101 times in the movie.
  • Sally Field was going through a real divorce while filming; Robin Williams divorced his wife to marry the nanny after making this movie.
  • Lisa Jakub (oldest daughter) got expelled from her Toronto school for 5 months of filming; Robin Williams wrote a letter asking to un-expel her – they didn't, but they framed the letter.
  • The exact address is 2640 Steiner St. in San Francisco.
  • 30 minutes of deleted scenes with the nosy neighbor were cut.
Apex Mountain
  • Robin Williams – yes; 5 top 10 movies in 6 years, Aladdin was #1, this was #2 in 1993; may never have been a bigger star.
  • Chris Columbus – yes; 'Home Alone' 1, 'Home Alone' 2, then 'Mrs. Doubtfire' making $441 million.
  • Divorce comedies – yes.
  • Old school San Francisco houses – yes.
  • Sally Field – no; Pierce Brosnan – no (but his chest hair: yes).
Picking nits
  • Sally Field should have let Daniel be the babysitter from 3-7, at least one more chance before hiring a maid.
  • Daniel had no plan for the nanny name – he looked at the newspaper for 'Mrs. Doubtfire' on the spot.
  • Would Pierce Brosnan's character really settle down with a divorced mom with 3 kids and a messy ex?
  • Parents having a loud divorce fight in the kitchen where kids can overhear.
  • The kids watching Dick Van Dyke – 'no 14-year-old is watching that in 1993'.
Sequel, prequel, prestige TV or untouchable?
  • All three say No; Shea: 'This should not even have been a 2 hour and 8 minute movie'.
  • Amanda: 'The central premise just can't be updated'.
(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • Did Sally Field's character ever actually like Daniel? What was their foundation?
  • Did she wind up with Pierce Brosnan? (They filmed about 4 different endings).
  • Was the pepper incident attempted murder? Should 'Mrs. Doubtfire' have gone to jail?
What memorabilia would you want (or not want!) from the movie?
  • The house at 2640 Steiner St. (Bill).
  • Membership to the pool club – the Claremont Club and Spa, north of Berkeley (Amanda).
  • The pony from the party scene (Shea).
Who won the movie?

Robin Williams – unanimous agreement.

Producer review

Craig Horlbeck (born 1994): one of the biggest childhood movies – on the Mount Rushmore with 'Home Alone' and Sandlot; for people under 35, when they think Robin Williams it's 'Mrs. Doubtfire' 'not even close'.