January 18, 2022

'Miracle'

Do you believe in Rewatchables?! The Ringer's Bill Simmons and Chris Ryan head back to Lake Placid in the 1980 Winter Olympics to rewatch 'Miracle,' starring Kurt Russell.

Movie poster

Cast

Kurt Russell as Herb Brooks

Patricia Clarkson as Patty Brooks

Noah Emmerich as Craig Patrick

Eddie Cahill as Jim Craig

Michael Mantenuto as Jack O'Callahan

Directed by: Gavin O'Connor

Written by: Eric Guggenheim

Notes

  • $28 million budget, made $64 million at the box office.
  • Part of the 'one star on the poster' era of sports movies (1997-2005): one big star, ~$15M budget, make $30-40M. Examples include Remember the Titans, 'Varsity Blues', The Rookie, Coach Carter.
  • Kurt Russell was the only actor considered for Herb Brooks – O'Connor was focused on him from the start because he looked like Brooks, understood sports, and played sports.
  • They cast 4,000 people for the 20 player roles, choosing real hockey players over actors – 'easier to teach hockey players to act than actors to play hockey.'
  • Buzz Schneider's real-life son Billy was cast to play his father, which they didn't realize until after casting him.
  • Bill Ranford, former Edmonton Oilers goalie, served as the hockey stunt double for Jim Craig in all on-ice goalie scenes.
  • Kurt Russell took a pay cut so the 800-1,000 extras used as hockey fans could enjoy a full hot meal instead of a brown bag lunch.
  • Kurt Russell is right-handed but used his left hand in the movie because Herb Brooks was a lefty.
  • The USSR game was filmed at the PNE Agrodome in Vancouver – the same venue used for the 'Rocky'/Drago fight in 'Rocky IV'.
  • Gavin O'Connor has a cameo: he's the person who drapes the American flag on Jim Craig after the gold medal game.
  • Michael Mantenuto (OC) got the role after getting into a real fight during auditions – O'Connor liked his toughness. Mantenuto later left acting, joined the U.S. Army Green Berets, fought ISIS, and tragically committed suicide in 2017.
  • Herb Brooks died in a car accident before the movie was released and never saw the finished film.
  • Al Michaels re-recorded all his play-by-play audio for the movie, except for the final 10 seconds ('Do you believe in miracles?') which uses his original 1980 call.
  • Kurt Russell told Bill on his podcast that the key to cracking the character came when he met the real Herb Brooks, who described that Olympic year in one word: 'Lonely.'
  • Bill wrote about this movie for ESPN The Magazine in 2004. His original ending said he wasn't going to see it, but ESPN/Disney made him change it since it was a Disney film.
  • The Sports Illustrated cover of the 1980 team celebrating was one of only two SI covers ever with no cover text – just the photo.
  • Best Actor nominees the year 'Miracle' came out: Jamie Foxx won for Ray; they argue Russell could have replaced Johnny Depp's Finding Neverland nomination.
  • Kurt Russell's top 5 movies per Bill: 1) Escape from New York, 2) The Thing, 3) 'Tombstone', 4) 'Tango and Cash', 5) 'Miracle'.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

I propose all future movies about workaholics just make them bachelors to spare us the dead air.
  • Ebert gave it two stars. Bill thought it deserved at least two and a half.
  • Ebert: 'Miracle is a sports movie that's more about the coach than about the team.'
Most re-watchable scene
  • The entire third period of the USSR game.
  • Herb picks the 26-man roster in an hour – 'I'm not looking for the best players, I'm looking for the right ones.'
  • OC fighting McClanahan over the cheap shot – classic Boston-Minnesota rivalry.
  • Herb makes everyone do sprints ('herbies') after the exhibition game until Rizzo says 'I play for the United States of America.'
  • Herb's pregame speech: 'If we played them 10 times, they might win nine. But not this game. Not tonight.'
  • Herb before the third period: 'Listen to them' – pointing at the crowd.
  • OC finding out he made the team – 'I swear to God, Herb, if you're not being serious right now.'
  • Herb goading McClanahan into playing injured: 'A bruise on the leg is a hell of a long way from the heart, Candy.'
What aged the best?
  • The opening credits Cold War history lesson – Watergate, gas shortage, Ayatollah Khomeini, Carter malaise speech.
  • The hockey filming – using real hockey players instead of actors was a genius choice.
  • Al Michaels re-recording his play-by-play audio for the movie, narrating the entire third act.
  • Noah Emmerich's performance as Craig Patrick.
  • The BU vs. Minnesota rivalry stuff.
  • Herb's line in the third period: 'He doesn't know what to do' – about the Soviet coach not pulling his goalie.
What aged the worst?
  • Herb Brooks died in a car accident before the movie came out and never saw it.
  • This movie ruined all subsequent USA Olympic hockey expectations – everyone wanted lightning to strike twice.
  • The Patricia Clarkson wife character – a terrible example of the thankless 'sports movie wife' trope.
  • No profanity – these hockey players absolutely swore constantly, and the PG rating robs the movie of authenticity.
Casting what-ifs
  • O'Connor was locked on Kurt Russell from the start.
  • 4,000 people auditioned for the 20 player roles.
  • Michael Mantenuto got cast as OC after getting in a real fight during auditions.
  • Chris suggests 2004-era actors: Ryan Gosling, Paul Dano, Josh Hartnett, Taylor Kitsch (who was basically a professional hockey player from Canada).
Best "that guy"
  • Eddie Cahill as Jim Craig – 'that guy from CSI: New York.'
  • Kenneth Welsh as Doc – 'he's in Twin Peaks, he's in everything.'
  • Sean McCann as Walter, the guy who gets Herb the coaching job.
Over-acting award
  • Kurt Russell in the 'Again!' sprints scene – dialing it up to 11.
  • Some of the hockey player-actors in the bar scenes.
Best "heat check" performance
  • Al Michaels – essentially narrating the climax of the movie as himself.
  • The Russian coach – no lines but great facial expressions: evil, confused, angry, then begrudging respect.
  • OC (Michael Mantenuto).
Half-assed (internet) research
  • Kurt Russell took a pay cut so extras could get hot meals instead of brown bag lunches.
  • Russell is right-handed but used his left hand because Herb Brooks was a lefty.
  • The USSR game was filmed at the PNE Agrodome in Vancouver – the same venue as 'Rocky' IV's Drago fight.
  • 'Dream On' by Aerosmith plays in the closing credits.
  • Michael Mantenuto left acting, joined the Green Berets, fought ISIS, and committed suicide in 2017.
  • Jim Craig really did stop 39 shots (shots were 39-16).
Apex Mountain
  • Kurt Russell: 'Tombstone' is the consensus apex.
  • Gavin O'Connor: No.
  • Olympic hockey / Winter Olympics: Yes.
  • Sports Illustrated: Bill argues 1980 was the apex – the 'Miracle' on Ice cover was iconic.
  • Al Michaels: The 1980 call was the greatest moment of his career, then re-voicing the movie in 2004 at the pinnacle of his Monday Night Football powers.
  • Best motivational speech in sports movie history? Top 3: 'Miracle', 'Friday Night Lights', Al Pacino in 'Any Given Sunday'.
Picking nits
  • Soviet coach benching Tretiak – the all-time worst coaching decision, still inexplicable.
  • The Lake Placid crowd doesn't feel big enough – only 800-1,000 extras for what should be 8,500 fans.
  • They skip over the Finland gold medal game.
  • The movie is 2 hours 17 minutes, which is too long – Disney sports movies are always 20 minutes too long.
  • The transition between the second and third periods of the USSR game is clumsy.
Sequel, prequel, prestige TV or untouchable?
  • Bill thinks it could work, especially given the HBO Lakers series proving the concept.
  • Chris suggests cross-cutting between the Russian and American sides.
  • Chris: Explore what happens to the players after – how do you live up to the biggest sports moment ever?
What memorabilia would you want (or not want!) from the movie?
  • Chris: Herb's plaid bell-bottom pants.
  • Bill: The Rizzo jersey (Mike Eruzione USA jersey).
  • Chris: Jim Craig's post-game outfit – hockey pants, suspenders, tank top, beanie.
  • Bill owns two unripped tickets from the actual 1980 USA-Russia game, purchased for $800-1,000 at a collectors convention.
(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • Would Woj/Twitter ruin the tape-delay surprise of the 1980 game if it happened today?
  • The Ralph Cox sequel – what happened to Coxie after getting cut?
  • Could a team galvanize the entire country the way the 1980 team did today?
Who won the movie?

Kurt Russell – unanimous, not even a debate.

Producer review
  • Craig Horlbeck says this is really up there for sports movies, though Remember the Titans is still his favorite.
  • Most impressed by the filming – the real hockey hits and the fluid camera work.