May 31, 2021

'Memento'

The Ringer's Bill Simmons and Chris Ryan rush to the nearest tattoo parlor to remind themselves to rewatch Christopher Nolan's 'Memento,' starring Guy Pearce, Carrie-Anne Moss, and Joe Pantoliano.

Movie poster

Cast

Guy Pearce as Leonard Shelby

Carrie-Anne Moss as Natalie

Stephen Tobolowsky as Sammy Jankis

Directed by: Christopher Nolan

Written by: Christopher Nolan

Notes

  • $4.5 million budget, made $40 million total; Oscar nominations for Best Original Screenplay and Best Editing.
  • Nolan shot the movie in 25 days; the story originated from Jonathan Nolan pitching the idea on a road trip from Georgetown to LA.
  • Every studio head passed because it was 'too confusing'; Soderbergh championed it everywhere; Harvey Weinstein tried to buy it after passing.
  • The categories were intentionally presented out of order as a meta-joke to match the movie's non-linear structure.
  • Teddy's phone number is the same as Marla Singer's in 'Fight Club'.
  • On the limited edition DVD, you can watch the movie chronologically.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

Confusion is a state we are intended to be in.
  • Ebert concluded that greater understanding helped on the plot level but didn't enrich the viewing experience.
  • Bill notes this isn't really an Ebert kind of movie – 'it probably broke his brain'.
Most re-watchable scene
  • Lenny kills Teddy – the first 6 minutes; 'Beg my wife's forgiveness before I blow your brains out' (Bill's pick).
  • Leonard goes off in his flannel and the transition from black and white to color – killing Jimmy then Teddy's reveal (Chris's pick).
  • Carrie-Anne Moss flipping out on Leonard – hiding the pens, getting him to hit her, then coming back claiming another guy did it.
  • First Carrie-Anne Moss diner scene – 'We're both survivors'; totally different on rewatches knowing what she did.
  • The diabetes/insulin reveal with Teddy telling Leonard the truth – 'You lie to yourself to be happy'.
What aged the best?
  • One of the first movie websites – Jonathan Nolan designed it with clues like 'The Blair Witch Project'.
  • Anterograde amnesia depicted realistically – medical experts praised it as one of the most accurate depictions in film.
  • Guy Pearce's improvised narration – Bill isn't usually a narrator fan but it worked.
  • Subtle physical comedy – Leonard pushing a pull door, the hotel clerk renting him two rooms.
  • Nolan's shooting style: anamorphic lenses, camera always closer to Pearce to put the audience inside Leonard's head.
  • Tujunga/Valley locations – that grimy down-and-out Valley vibe.
What aged the worst?
  • This movie will never match the experience of seeing it the first time – a unique class of movies where nothing replicates initial discovery.
  • Guy Pearce's career – 'if you had his rookie cards after 'Memento', you took a hit'.
Casting what-ifs
  • Brad Pitt was initially slated to play Leonard; after passing, Nolan said he didn't want a movie star anyway.
  • Aaron Eckhart and Thomas Jane were also considered; Bill thinks Thomas Jane would have been really good.
  • Bill's controversial take: this would have been an amazing Brad Pitt movie, between 'Fight Club' and Ocean's 11.
  • Paranoid Android by Radiohead was going to be in the closing credits but was too expensive for the $4.5M budget.
Over-acting award

The drug dealer that Leonard hits over the head – one reason Bill wanted Nicky Katt for the re-casting.

Best "that guy"
  • Joe Pantoliano automatically wins because the award is named after him – they decide he auto-wins when he's in the movie.
  • Runner-up: Mark Boone Junior (Burt, the Discount Inn front desk guy) – Two Fast Two Furious, 'Batman' Begins, Sons of Anarchy.
  • Callum Keith Rennie as Dodd also mentioned.
Best "heat check" performance
  • Mark Boone Junior as Burt.
  • Runner-up: the coked-up escort/prostitute.
Re-casting couch
  • The drug dealer: Nicky Katt (Chris) or Michael Imperioli (Bill – still gettable, just Spider from 'Goodfellas').
  • Michael Madsen or Tom Sizemore also mentioned.
Half-assed (internet) research
  • Newmarket gave it $4.5M; screened for studio heads who all liked it but passed because it was 'too confusing'.
  • Soderbergh championed it; Newmarket distributed it themselves to ~500 theaters.
  • Harvey Weinstein passed, then tried to buy it afterwards and couldn't.
  • Teddy's 'you freak' line is actually Nolan's voice, not Pantoliano's – they felt Pants didn't nail it.
  • Teddy's phone number is the same as Marla Singer's in 'Fight Club'.
Apex Mountain
  • Guy Pearce – yes, this is Apex Mountain for him.
  • Carrie-Anne Moss – yes, even over The Matrix (Chris agrees).
  • Anterograde amnesia – yes, absolutely Apex Mountain for the condition.
  • The Discount Inn – yes, when has a discount inn ever been more prominent?
  • Tan suits – fun pick from Chris; Pearce keeps that suit crisp despite living in it for a week.
  • Christopher Nolan – no (his apex is later); Joey Pantoliano – no (The Sopranos).
Picking nits

Teddy should just kill Lenny much earlier – he's so dangerous and unpredictable that Teddy is now in danger himself.

Sequel, prequel, prestige TV or untouchable?
  • Yes – Leonard as basically a killer-for-hire for different people, each episode following a different manipulation.
  • Chris: what if it was told from Burt's (the hotel guy's) perspective?
  • Probably can't do it backwards for TV – too confusing.
(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • Was there a second attacker? Bill thinks no – Leonard is Sammy Jankis.
  • Did Leonard's wife kill herself or did he accidentally kill her with insulin shots? They think the Sammy Jankis story is really Leonard's story.
  • What happens to this movie in the era of mobile phone video? Leonard could create a vlog.
  • Is Leonard in the mental institution at the end? There's a quick flash of him replacing Sammy Jankis.
  • Why didn't this movie have 10 sequels? Why wasn't this 'Saw'?
What memorabilia would you want (or not want!) from the movie?
  • The first Polaroid – the one Leonard is holding at the beginning (Bill).
  • The Jaguar, even with the window blown out (Chris).
Who won the movie?

Christopher Nolan – comes out of essentially nowhere and for $5 million makes a movie that looks better than 99% of all other films.