'Coming to America'
The Ringer's Bill Simmons and Van Lathan are joined by the New York Times' Wesley Morris to pick up a shift at McDowell's and revisit the 1988 classic 'Coming to America' starring Eddie Murphy, Arsenio Hall, James Earl Jones, and John Amos.

Cast
Eddie Murphy as Prince Akeem / Clarence / Saul / Randy Watson
Arsenio Hall as Semmi / Reverend Brown / Extremely Ugly Girl / Morris
James Earl Jones as King Jaffe Joffer
John Amos as Cleo McDowell
Shari Headley as Lisa McDowell
Eriq La Salle as Darryl Jenks
Madge Sinclair as Queen Aoleon
Allison Dean as Patrice McDowell
Paul Bates as Oha
Samuel L. Jackson as Hold-Up Man
Frankie Faison as Landlord
Directed by: John Landis
Written by: Barry Blaustein, David Sheffield
Notes
- Second biggest movie of 1988 (behind 'Rain Man'); made over $200 million.
- Murphy earned $8 million plus 15% of film rentals. Weekly expenditures during production: $3,800/week for custom motorhome, $1,500/week for personal trainer, $650/week for valet, $5,000/week living allowance.
- Nominated for two Oscars: Best Costume Design and Best Makeup (Rick Baker).
- Major Eddie Murphy/John Landis feud: Landis called Murphy 'the pig of the world, the most unpleasant, arrogant... just an asshole.' Murphy countered that he hired Landis to save his career after the Twilight Zone tragedy.
- Art Buchwald lawsuit: Buchwald wrote a 1982 script treatment with essentially the same plot. Paramount optioned it, then abandoned it in 1985. Buchwald won the breach of contract suit.
- McDowell's was actually a Wendy's on Queens Boulevard that was about to be closed.
- Rick Baker (Thriller makeup artist) did all the prosthetic makeup; Paramount executives visited set and didn't recognize Eddie in the Saul character.
- Multiple-characters approach became an Eddie staple (Nutty Professor, The Klumps, Norbit).
- Zamunda name taken from a Richard Pryor routine.
- A CBS sitcom pilot was made with Tommy Davidson playing the prince; didn't get picked up.
- Only all-Black-cast movie in the top 20 of 1988.
- Paula Abdul choreographed the dance sequences.
- The movie's cultural impact on ending the Jheri curl trend (via Soul Glow mockery).
- Armond White wrote a scathing review; Murphy responded with a paid advertisement in the newspaper.
Categories
- Bill: Black Awareness Week / Sexual Chocolate / Randy Watson performance.
- Van: the barbershop scenes – endlessly quotable, Joe Louis age bit.
- Wesley: the resolution scene where all characters come together at the end.
- Also discussed: the opening Zamunda presentation, the first nightclub scene (Arsenio in drag), Akeem's first date with Lisa, and the King arrives / John Amos vs. James Earl Jones dad-off.
- The Mortimer and Randolph 'Trading Places' crossover cameo.
- The barbershop scenes – short, endlessly quotable.
- Darryl and Soul Glow essentially killing the Jheri curl.
- 'The Royal Penis is clean, your highness.'
- The McDowell's vs. McDonald's explanation.
- Louie Anderson's cameo – got a second life via Kanye's Gold Digger.
- The Jewish barber character – Landis's idea, incredible Rick Baker makeup.
- Every Black woman in the movie having aged fantastically (Vanessa Bell Calloway, Garcelle Beauvais, Shari Headley).
- 117-minute runtime – should be ~105 min, especially the first 20 minutes before they get to New York.
- John Amos's cultural significance being harder to explain 33 years later.
- Arsenio Hall's character being named 'Semmi.'
- Eriq La Salle being typecast as the Soul Glow guy for years.
- John Landis's post-movie career collapse.
- The 'Coming to America' theme song by The System – missed opportunity for a better soundtrack.
- Some dated 1988 treatment of women and gender dynamics.
- Vanessa Williams originally considered for Lisa McDowell.
- Sidney Poitier was approached for King Jaffe Joffer – turned it down, did Shoot to Kill instead.
- Paul Gleason was asked to reprise Clarence Beaks from 'Trading Places' in the Duke Brothers scene but was filming 'Die Hard'.
- Winner: Allison Dean as Patrice McDowell (the sister).
- Madge Sinclair as the Queen.
- Paul Bates as Oha, the ceremonial herald – also appeared in 'True Romance'.
- Frankie Faison as the slumlord.
- Eddie Murphy exempt – his multiple characters are the movie's engine.
- Winner: Allison Dean as Patrice McDowell – 'just a great Dion Waiters performance.'
- Also: Louie Anderson, Samuel L. Jackson (one scene).
- Special spinoff – best character played by Eddie/Arsenio: Eddie in the barbershop wins.
- Could we have done better than Shari Headley? Robin Givens floated (rejected – would ruin her 'Boomerang' performance) and Angela Bassett (would have been 28 but would a white casting agent in 1987 have found her?).
- Consensus: Shari Headley works well because of her sweetness.
- McDowell's was a Wendy's on Queens Boulevard about to be closed.
- Murphy's salary and weekly expenditure details.
- The Murphy-Landis feud quotes.
- The Art Buchwald lawsuit.
- The Armond White review and Murphy's paid newspaper response.
- The CBS sitcom pilot with Tommy Davidson.
- Zamunda from Richard Pryor. St. John's beat Marist 66-59 in the game shown.
- Eddie Murphy – no (this isn't his apex).
- Arsenio Hall – yes (this movie plus about to get the talk show).
- James Earl Jones – debated extensively (Darth Vader? Sandlot? Fences on stage? 'Field of Dreams'? Possibly 'Apexless' – always present, never peaking).
- Shari Headley – yes. Allison Dean – yes. Clint Smith – yes.
- Hot tubs – discussed ('Coming to America' hot tub is compelling but SNL Eddie as James Brown in the hot tub may edge it).
- Jheri curls – this is 'the nadir of the apex.'
- Barbershop conversations – debated (the Barbershop movie franchise gets the nod over this).
- Would the king really send his son to NYC without bodyguards?
- Where did Semmi keep getting cash (repeated money clips)?
- McDonald's would have sued McDowell's out of business immediately.
- Why didn't Arsenio Hall do more movies?
- Did Hakeem Olajuwon add the 'H' to his name because of this movie?
- Did Wakanda rip off Zamunda or vice versa?
- Why didn't Akeem stay at the Waldorf AND get a second apartment?
- Bill: the McDowell's cheeseburger phone.
- Van: the gold hair dryer.
- Wesley: Akeem's necklace with red threads between blocks.
Eddie Murphy. Unanimous, no debate. Best supporting: Arsenio Hall.