'The Usual Suspects'
The greatest trick The Ringer's Bill Simmons and Chris Ryan ever pulled was convincing the world they didn't exist. We head to the docks of San Pedro to rewatch 'The Usual Suspects,' starring Kevin Spacey, Gabriel Byrne, and Stephen Baldwin.

Cast
Kevin Spacey as Verbal Kint / Keyser Soze
Gabriel Byrne as Dean Keaton
Chazz Palminteri as Agent Dave Kujan
Stephen Baldwin as McManus
Kevin Pollak as Todd Hockney
Benicio del Toro as Fenster
Pete Postlethwaite as Kobayashi
Peter Greene as Redfoot
Suzy Amis as Edie Finneran
Giancarlo Esposito as Jack Baer
Directed by: Bryan Singer
Written by: Christopher McQuarrie
Notes
- Budget $6 million; made $34 million at the box office.
- Kevin Spacey won Oscar for Best Supporting Actor; Christopher McQuarrie won Oscar for Best Original Screenplay.
- None of the actors knew who Keyser Soze was – Singer filmed extra scenes to mislead them.
- Gabriel Byrne was so stunned he wasn't Keyser Soze that he stormed off into the parking lot after the screening; Singer had to calm him down for half an hour.
- Del Toro deliberately developed his mumbling because he didn't love his part; his farting on set is why the actors crack up during the lineup scene.
- The redfoot cigarette flick into Stephen Baldwin's face was actually an accident – Baldwin's reaction is genuine.
- Stephen Baldwin and Kevin Pollak have a long-standing feud that started during filming; neither will say what caused it.
- When Keaton hands out the folders Kobayashi gave them, they're handed out in the order the characters die.
- Singer described the film as 'Double Indemnity meets Rashomon'; the title came from a Spy Magazine article.
- Spacey's 1995: won Supporting Actor Oscar for this + starred in 'Se7en' – only 6 actors have won both Best Actor and Best Supporting Actor.
- Significant opening discussion about whether a movie can get 'canceled' for off-screen allegations against Spacey and Singer.
Categories
Quote from Rog's review:
“To the degree that I do understand, I don't care.”
- Ebert put it on his 'most hated films list' – called it 'confusing and uninteresting'.
- The hosts speculate Ebert had 'guys saying fuck you to each other fatigue' from the flood of post-Tarantino crime films.
- The reveal / ending sequence – Spacey's last scene with Palminteri, the bulletin board, the limp straightening (Bill and Chris's pick).
- The lineup / interrogation combo (first 17 minutes) – a 'master class' introduction of the characters.
- Stephen Baldwin's 'give me the fucking keys, you fucking cocksucker' in the lineup.
- Kobayashi's first scene laying out the conspiracy.
- The Keyser Soze origin story – 'showed these men of will what will really was'.
- The boat shootout – 'there's no fucking coke'.
- Every actor's performance – a 'who stole the movie' situation with Pollak, Baldwin, Del Toro all competing.
- The poster – '25 years later, still great'.
- The Chazz Palminteri / Spacey interrogation scenes – 35 minutes together, shot in about a week, like a play.
- The fax machine slowly revealing the suspect's face – a 90s trope that no longer exists.
- Kevin Spacey and Bryan Singer's off-screen baggage – the movie essentially got 'canceled' for things unrelated to the film.
- Stephen Baldwin wearing a Confederate flag soldier hat with a motorcycle jacket – 'the worst outfit of the 90s'.
- The twist is now impossible to preserve in the internet age.
- Chazz Palminteri's hair/wig – 'starting to look like Burt Reynolds in Stroker Ace'.
- Michael Biehn was the first choice for McManus; Singer called Baldwin a 'huge mistake' after the fact.
- Christopher Walken and Robert De Niro both turned down the Kujan role; Al Pacino also came in to read.
- Redfoot was offered to Walken, Tommy Lee Jones, Jeff Bridges, Charlie Sheen, James Spader, Al Pacino, and Johnny Cash.
- Singer & McQuarrie sent the screenplay to Spacey without telling him which role – Spacey assumed Kujan or Keaton.
- Stephen Baldwin – 'give me the fucking keys, you fucking cocksucker' (winner).
- Kevin Pollak – 'fuck your father in the shower and then have a snack'.
- Peter Greene as Redfoot (Bill's pick / winner).
- Giancarlo Esposito.
- Pete Postlethwaite as Kobayashi.
Suzy Amis replaced with Laura Linney – Bill is 'not a Suzy Amis fan'.
- The folders are handed out in the order the characters die.
- Gabriel Byrne nearly backed out for 24 hours due to going through a divorce.
- Del Toro developed his mumbling to stand out; his farting on set caused the lineup laughter.
- The cigarette flick into Baldwin's face was an accident – genuine reaction.
- Baldwin and Pollak have a long-standing feud from filming – 'the 2Pac and Biggie of independent 90s film actors'.
- Peter Greene's career derailed due to drug problems.
- The Baldwin Brothers as a troika: Yes – Alec was A-minus list, Billy was being pushed (Sliver, Flatliners, Backdraft), Stephen had this.
- Stephen Baldwin: Definitely yes – this was his peak.
- Kevin Pollak: Yes – Few Good Men was in the rearview, regular on Letterman and Conan.
- Chazz Palminteri: Yes – had so much juice he helped get the movie funded.
- Peter Greene: Yes – 'Pulp Fiction' '94, Usual Suspects '95, then it went the other way.
- Kevin Spacey: No – American Beauty is probably his Apex.
- Gabriel Byrne: No – Miller's Crossing.
- Limping: Yes – the greatest limp ever filmed.
- Turkish crime lords: Yes.
- Palminteri never finds it suspicious that the one crippled guy survived the boat explosion without a mark.
- The way Keyser Soze is described as this fearsome figure doesn't match Kevin Spacey at all.
- Some of the crimes Kobayashi assigns seem like small stakes for a $91 million cocaine guy.
- Why wasn't Kevin Pollak a bigger star? 'Bad job by his agent'.
- What is Palminteri's next day at the office like after completely blowing it?
- Keyser Soze vs. Neil McCauley (from Heat) – who wins?
- Couldn't Soze have come up with a simpler way to get the witness than a massive gun battle?
'The perfect 6-episode BBC-style limited series' – if the twist happened in the finale like Big Little Lies, 'you would be shitting yourself'.
- Christopher McQuarrie – the script is one of the all-time greats and McQuarrie went on to 'Mission: Impossible' films.
- In 2015 the answer would have been Spacey, but 'now that this movie has shifted, it's McQuarrie'.