'Toy Story'
You've got a friend in The Ringer's Sean Fennessey, Mallory Rubin, and Shea Serrano. That's right – it's time for the 1995 Pixar classic 'Toy Story,' featuring Tom Hanks, Tim Allen, and Don Rickles.

Cast
Tom Hanks as Woody (voice)
Tim Allen as Buzz Lightyear (voice)
Don Rickles as Mr. Potato Head (voice)
Wallace Shawn as Rex (voice)
R. Lee Ermey as Sarge (voice)
Directed by: John Lasseter
Written by: Joss Whedon, Andrew Stanton
Music by: Randy Newman
Notes
- First animated film covered on The Rewatchables.
- Budget $30 million; grossed $373 million; 100% on Rotten Tomatoes.
- Only 110 people in full production (compared to 800 for The Lion King).
- First animated film nominated for Best Original Screenplay at the Oscars.
- John Lasseter received a special achievement Academy Award – only 15 total in Oscar history.
- Disney pushed for it to be a musical; Lasseter compromised – songs play at key moments but aren't sung by characters.
- Original treatment had Woody as the villain (a ventriloquist dummy) abusing other toys; Jeffrey Katzenberg pushed Lasseter to reshape it as a buddy picture.
- Tom Hanks recorded dialogue during breaks of 'Sleepless in Seattle' and 'A League of Their Own' – not during 'Philadelphia' or 'Forrest Gump' (didn't want comedy between serious roles).
- The carpet in Sid's house matches the hexagonal pattern from The Shining's Overlook Hotel.
- Early title for the film was 'You Are a Toy'; Buzz was originally going to be named 'Lunar Larry'.
- Sid Phillips inspired by a former Pixar employee known for disassembling toys.
- The misfit toys sequence in Sid's house is a beat-for-beat homage to Todd Browning's Freaks (1932).
Categories
Quote from Rog's review:
“I felt I was in at the dawn of a new era of movie animation, which draws on the best of the old, and creates something new.”
Ebert called it 'a visionary roller coaster ride of a movie' and said he 'felt some of the same exhilaration I felt during Who Framed Roger Rabbit'.
- Woody and Buzz's showdown at the gas station – 'You are a toy!' (Sean's pick).
- Buzz realizing he's a toy / seeing his own commercial on TV (Mallory's pick).
- The opening montage with 'You've Got a Friend in Me' (Shea's pick).
- The Claw sequence at Pizza Planet – 'I have been chosen. Farewell, my friends. I go on to a better place.'
- Mrs. Nesbit scene – Buzz's breakdown after losing his arm.
- The toys scaring Sid.
- The animation – still looks incredible 25 years later; revolutionary for digital animation.
- Disney betting on Pixar – bridged the gap after Disney's 2D golden age.
- Randy Newman's music – 'You've Got a Friend in Me' discussed as being in the running for best original song in movie history.
- The 81-minute runtime – great pacing, glides through.
- The themes – coming of age, identity, purpose, friendship, existential dread, the fear of being replaced/forgotten.
- The indescribable attachment children have to their toys – still resonates.
Mallory's hot take: the runtime is too short at 82 minutes – feels like a TV episode (Sean and Shea roasted her for this).
- Billy Crystal was offered Buzz Lightyear but declined; later called it 'the biggest mistake of his career'.
- Chevy Chase and Bill Murray were also considered for Buzz.
- Jim Carrey was Pixar's original choice for Buzz but they couldn't afford him.
- Paul Newman was originally wanted for Woody (to represent Old Hollywood vs. New Hollywood).
- Rick Moranis was approached for Rex.
Wallace Shawn as Rex – 'Rex is so over the top,' though it's intentional (Mallory's pick).
- R. Lee Ermey as Sarge (Shea's pick).
- Eric von Detten as Sid – also the actor from Brink and The Princess Diaries (Mallory's pick).
- John Ratzenberger as Hamm – voices a character in virtually every Pixar movie.
- Wallace Shawn as Rex.
- Don Rickles as Mr. Potato Head (winner).
- John Ratzenberger as Hamm.
- Denzel Washington as Buzz Lightyear – 'it's a whole different movie' (Shea's pick).
- Sean says the cast is perfect and he wouldn't recast anybody.
- First animated film nominated for Best Original Screenplay at the Oscars.
- Lasseter received a special achievement Academy Award – only 15 total in Oscar history.
- Hasbro denied use of 'GI Joe' name because the doll would be blown up; became 'Combat Carl'.
- The Binford toolbox is the same brand from Tim Allen's Home Improvement.
- The toy shark's 'Howdy, howdy, howdy' references a Gary Larson Far Side comic.
- Buzz Lightyear was named after Buzz Aldrin.
- Tom Hanks in 1995: Wins second Oscar ('Forrest Gump'), releases Apollo 13 and 'Toy Story' within five months, films That Thing You Do – 'possibly the highest Apex Mountain in the history of the show'.
- Steve Jobs: Executive produced 'Toy Story' while simultaneously on the brink of returning to Apple.
- Why doesn't Buzz try to interact with Andy if he thinks he's a real space ranger? Why does he freeze when humans come in?
- Toys on foot and an RC car can somehow catch an actual moving truck.
- The moving truck at the end is nearly empty – where is all the family's stuff?
- Woody knocking Buzz out the window feels out of character for someone who's always the planner.
- Can toys die? Or just be destroyed?
- Do all Buzz Lightyears believe they are Space Rangers out of the box?
- Is Woody an asshole? (Consensus: not an asshole, but can behave like one – complex, insecure character).
- Who hurt Sid? What's going on with his family life?
- Is Emily (Jessie's original owner from 'Toy Story' 2) actually Andy's mom?
Consensus: No – 'the brevity is what's so brilliant'.
Woody – unanimous. The entire 'Toy Story' franchise hinges on Woody's choices, growth, and sense of self.