October 19, 2020

'Spotlight'

The Ringer's Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, and Ryen Russillo take a trip to The Boston Globe to revisit the Best Picture Oscar-winning 2015 film 'Spotlight' starring Michael Keaton, Mark Ruffalo, and Rachel McAdams. Directed by Tom McCarthy

Movie poster

Cast

Michael Keaton as Robby Robinson

Mark Ruffalo as Mike Rezendes

Rachel McAdams as Sacha Pfeiffer

Liev Schreiber as Marty Baron

John Slattery as Ben Bradlee Jr.

Stanley Tucci as Mitchell Garabedian

Billy Crudup as Eric MacLeish

Brian d'Arcy James as Matt Carroll

Directed by: Tom McCarthy

Written by: Tom McCarthy, Josh Singer

Music by: Howard Shore

Notes

  • $20 million budget, made $98.3 million at the box office.
  • Won Best Picture and Best Original Screenplay at the Oscars.
  • Only got one acting nomination: Ruffalo for Supporting Actor (over Keaton, Slattery, Schreiber).
  • Tom McCarthy also plays disgraced journalist Scott Templeton on The Wire Season 5 – ironic given he then made this movie about great journalism.
  • The overacting category on The Rewatchables was originally named after Ruffalo's 'They knew' speech.
  • Tom McCarthy built the Globe set so accurately that real reporters gravitated to their actual (fake) desks.
  • In the baseball game scene, the real Michael, Sacha, and Robby are in the background.
  • Described as 'maybe the most invisible Rewatchable we've ever done' – no flashy shots, perfectly calibrated performances.
  • Russillo calls it 'the best Boston movie without trying to be the Boston movie'.

Categories

Most re-watchable scene
  • Marty Baron's speech at the end: 'Sometimes it's easy to forget that we spend most of our time stumbling around the dark...' (Bill's pick).
  • The speakerphone call when they find out there could be 90 priests – the shot pulls back across the entire office (Chris's pick).
  • Ruffalo's 'It's time' speech: 'It's time, Robbie. They knew and they let it happen to kids'.
  • Baron telling the team to focus on the institution: 'Show me this was systemic, that it came from the top down'.
  • Sasha finding priest Paquin who admits 'I never raped anyone' and then the school bus appears.
What aged the best?
  • The Howard Shore piano score – nod to Dave Grusin's All the President's Men score.
  • Seeing Fenway Park in the Pedro era (pre-2004).
  • Tucci's line: 'If it takes a village to raise a child, it takes a village to abuse one'.
  • Billy Crudup as the smarmy lawyer.
  • The reporters leaving the Pulitzer out of the end credits (at the reporters' request).
What aged the worst?
  • The Curse of the Bambino book getting a shout-out.
  • The AOL Anywhere sign in front of the Globe.
  • Stanley Tucci's wig.
Casting what-ifs

Matt Damon almost got the Ruffalo/Mike Rezendes part – would have overpowered the movie in 2015.

Over-acting award

Mark Ruffalo – 'They knew! They knew!' – he was the original namesake for this category on The Rewatchables.

Best "that guy"
  • Jamey Sheridan as Jim the lawyer (Bill's pick).
  • Brian d'Arcy James as the 4th 'Spotlight' reporter Matt Carroll – huge stage actor, not widely known in film.
Best "heat check" performance
  • Billy Crudup – 3 scenes, makes the most of a nothing part; 'the most likable guy ever telling you to go fuck yourself'.
  • Stanley Tucci also nominated.
  • Patrick from Hyde Park/Jimmy LeBlanc – 1.5 scenes, crushes it.
Re-casting couch
  • Casey Affleck in Brian d'Arcy James's role as the 4th 'Spotlight' reporter.
  • Cole Hauser as an alternative for that same role.
Half-assed (internet) research
  • A visual blog rated the movie 76.2% for accuracy, which is apparently pretty good.
  • Premiered at Venice Film Festival to huge applause – and laughter when the end revealed Cardinal Law was reassigned to honor in Rome.
  • Tom McCarthy built the Globe set so accurately that real reporters gravitated to their actual desks.
  • John Geoghan, the priest who got the ball rolling, was murdered by a cellmate in 2003.
Apex Mountain
  • The Boston Globe – yes; they won the Pulitzer, the internet hasn't come for them yet.
  • Liev Schreiber – yes; Ray Donovan going at the same time plus this movie.
  • John Slattery – no, Mad Men is still his apex.
  • Rachel McAdams – no, 'The Notebook' is her apex.
  • Khakis – is there any film where khakis are more prominently worn?
Picking nits
  • They compressed some timelines (the Paquin priest scene happened after the first story, not before).
  • The Eric MacLeish character arc doesn't fully make sense: first protective, then it turns out he already mailed them the names.
Sequel, prequel, prestige TV or untouchable?

Could be a 10-episode Netflix show – 'a tough hang, but it would probably be pretty good'.

(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • Did this movie make up for Tom McCarthy's crime against journalism as Scott Templeton on The Wire?
  • Did Michael Keaton win the 2010s over Tom Hanks? (Birdman, 'Spotlight', The Founder vs. Hanks's weaker 2010s).
Who won the movie?
  • Michael Keaton (Bill and Chris's pick) – 'keeps the tempo in this movie, just the perfect tone the entire time'.
  • Mark Ruffalo (Russillo's pick) – 'awesome, single minded, he didn't care'.