September 28, 2020

'The Game'

The Ringer's Bill Simmons, Sean Fennessey, and Chris Ryan make their lives more fun by rewatching David Fincher's mysterious drama 'The Game' starring Michael Douglas, Sean Penn, and Deborah Kara Unger.

Movie poster

Cast

Michael Douglas as Nicholas Van Orton

Sean Penn as Conrad Van Orton

Deborah Kara Unger as Christine

James Rebhorn as Jim Feingold

Directed by: David Fincher

Written by: Andrew Kevin Walker

Notes

  • Part of 'David Fincher Week' on The Rewatchables – 'Se7en' was covered the week before.
  • Fincher himself doesn't like the movie – his producing partner cautioned him not to make it after 'Se7en' because of third-act problems.
  • Michael Douglas loved this movie – said it was what he was most proud of because you couldn't guess the ending.
  • Made on a ~$70 million budget and grossed $109 million.
  • Described as a '5-year rewatchable' – improves when you let a few years pass between viewings.
  • One of the last great thrillers you basically cannot make once smartphones and Google exist.
  • Spike Jonze is one of the paramedics in the final scene.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

The Game is like a Fincher film festival. It has the dark look and the brooding score. It has characters who seem in the grip of compulsions. And a plot that toys with the audience.

Ebert praised how it 'stays true to his paranoid vision right up until what seems like the very end and then beyond it.'

Most re-watchable scene
  • The entire final act – from the 300-person cafeteria/commissary reveal through the ending.
  • The presidential suite sequence – pickpocketing, finding coke and porn, the cab driver.
  • Nicholas returning to his house with fluorescent graffiti and 'White Rabbit' blaring.
  • Both Armin Mueller-Stahl scenes – the dressing down and throwing Polaroids.
  • Douglas and Sean Penn's birthday lunch where Conrad explains the game.
What aged the best?
  • Sean Penn's performance – remarkably believable, every scene with him is electric.
  • The Bay Area / San Francisco as a setting – Fincher's home base with incredible feel for the city.
  • Being a pre-smartphone/pre-Google thriller – one of the last great thrillers impossible to make once search engines exist.
  • Fincher's attention to detail and underground/underworld themes connecting to Social Network and 'Fight Club'.
What aged the worst?
  • The movie drags after Nicholas wakes up in Mexico – could have cut some scenes.
  • Deborah Kara Unger's career after this movie – this was essentially her peak.
  • The Super 8 footage flashbacks of the father's suicide – overused as a visual motif, feels un-Fincher-like.
Casting what-ifs
  • Originally to be made in 1992 with director Jonathan Mostow and Kyle MacLachlan and Bridget Fonda as leads.
  • Jodie Foster was announced for the Sean Penn part at 1996 Cannes – Fincher was uncomfortable with her being too big a star; she ended up suing for ~$54 million.
  • Jeff Bridges declined the Conrad role before Sean Penn was cast.
Best "that guy"
  • James Rebhorn as Jim Feingold – been in a million things including 'Scent of a Woman', 'The Talented Mr. Ripley', 'Se7en', and Homeland.
  • Peter Donat as the personal attorney – appeared in 'The Godfather Part II', was runner-up for Tom Hagen before Duvall.
Over-acting award

Sean Penn – 'dolls it up' particularly in the car scene: 'They just fuck you and fuck you and fuck you.' Said completely out of love – he's amazing.

Apex Mountain
  • Deborah Kara Unger – definitely yes.
  • Pre-Silicon Valley San Francisco movies – strong candidate, one of the last great SF movies before tech took over.
  • James Rebhorn – 'Cheeseburger on film Apex Mountain'.
Picking nits
  • Is it that easy to drain a multi-millionaire's bank accounts?
  • Nicholas reading account numbers aloud on the phone in front of Christine – no real bank would allow this.
  • What happens if Douglas doesn't jump off that specific part of the building? Massive CRS liability.
  • How long was he roofied? At least 5-6 hours to get to Mexico from San Francisco.
Re-casting couch
  • Diane Lane instead of Deborah Kara Unger – the perfect part for her.
  • Denzel Washington for Nicholas – can do the 'not a good guy but you're still interested' thing.
Sequel, prequel, prestige TV or untouchable?

Could work as a 10-episode Netflix show – anthology style where each season is a different person going through the game, or a workplace drama about CRS employees.

(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • What was the final bill for the game? Hosts estimate ~$5 million total (~$2.5 million each).
  • Did The Game cause a real person to jump? – Referenced an Unsolved Mysteries case of someone obsessed with the movie.
  • Who paid for Conrad's game originally?
Who won the movie?

Chris picks Douglas – old-school movie star carrying every scene. Bill and Sean lean toward Sean Penn – if a different actor is in the Conrad part, they're not doing this podcast.

Half-assed (internet) research
  • Spike Jonze is one of the paramedics in the final scene; Richard Masur (from 'Se7en') is the other.
  • The Criterion LaserDisc has an alternate ending where Nicholas just walks away – the hosts say it's really bad.
  • Deborah Kara Unger was cast after Fincher and Douglas watched her in Cronenberg's Crash.