June 15, 2020

'Fletch'

The Ringer's Bill Simmons, Sean Fennessey, and Chris Ryan charge it all to the Underhills' account after rewatching 'Fletch,' the 1985 comedy starring Chevy Chase, Dana Wheeler-Nicholson, and Joe Don Baker.

Movie poster

Cast

Chevy Chase as Irwin M. 'Fletch' Fletcher

Tim Matheson as Alan Stanwyck

Dana Wheeler-Nicholson as Gail Stanwyck

Joe Don Baker as Chief Karlin

Geena Davis as Larry

George Wendt as Fat Sam

M. Emmet Walsh as Dr. Dolan

Directed by: Michael Ritchie

Written by: Andrew Bergman

Music by: Harold Faltermeyer

Notes

  • Made on an $8 million budget and grossed $59 million domestic plus $24.4 million in video rentals.
  • Michael Douglas produced it and got it over the finish line.
  • Stanwyck's mansion is the same house used in 'The Godfather' where Jack Woltz finds the horse head in his bed.
  • Became a phenomenon through cable TV and Blockbuster rentals – the perfect TNT/TBS/Comedy Central movie at 1 hour 37 minutes.
  • Chevy Chase was considered for Animal House but was too big a star – Tim Matheson's character Otter was written as a Chevy Chase type.
  • Kevin Smith spent years in development hell trying to remake 'Fletch' with Jason Lee, but Harvey Weinstein said Lee wasn't a big enough name.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

Chase projects such an inflexible mask of cool detachment that we're prevented from identifying with him.

The hosts strongly disagree – Siskel nailed it, saying Chevy had been miscast for years and this was the perfect role.

Most re-watchable scene
  • 'Fletch' getting a physical with Dr. Dolan – 'Ever serve time?' / 'Moon River' – Bill's top pick.
  • Lakers dream sequence with Chick Hearn and Kareem Abdul-Jabbar.
  • 'Fletch' fixing airplanes with buck teeth – 'It's all ball bearings nowadays'.
  • Second tennis club visit – ordering caviar, Dom Perignon, all charged to Mr. Underhill; 'Can I borrow your towel? My car just hit a water buffalo'.
  • 'Fletch' steals the kid's car and escapes police, ends up at Fred Dorfman's lunch – 'Chase's best 90 seconds'.
  • Dr. Rosenpenis / the autopsy scene – 'You never get used to the smell'.
  • Dr. Dolan and 'Babar' – 'Two B's, one B-A-B-A-R' – Sean's top pick.
What aged the best?
  • Kareem Abdul-Jabbar's IMDb – Game of Death, Airplane!, 'Fletch'; possibly the most successful athlete-actor.
  • Complete list of Fletch's aliases: Ted Nugent, Arnold Babar, Dr. Rosenpenis, Igor Stravinsky, Gordon Liddy, Don Corleone, and more.
  • Harold Faltermeyer's music – 'Beverly Hills Cop' and 'Fletch' back-to-back leading to 'Top Gun'.
  • Michael Ritchie as director – incredible sports movie filmography.
  • Fletch's apartment with the Magic/Bird poster and basketball hoop.
What aged the worst?
  • Alan Stanwyck's murder plan is absurd and full of holes.
  • Dana Wheeler-Nicholson's acting – not a great actress, though she's 'the greatest hang of all time'.
  • Chevy Chase's wardrobe – wide-bottom jeans, white linen shirt with big collar, three buttons open.
Casting what-ifs
  • Burt Reynolds, Jeff Bridges, Charles Grodin, Mick Jagger, and Barry Bostwick were all considered for 'Fletch'.
  • The novel's author Gregory Mcdonald had rejection rights and rejected Reynolds and Jagger.
  • George Segal was considered and turned it down.
  • Richard Dreyfuss was originally wanted by the producer.
Best "that guy"
  • Richard Libertini as Frank the newspaper editor – winner.
  • George Wendt, M. Emmet Walsh, Kenneth Mars, Geena Davis, and Joe Don Baker also considered.
Over-acting award

Two-man race between Richard Libertini and Joe Don Baker – Baker seemed like he was in a completely different movie, a '1970s exploitation movie'.

Best "heat check" performance
  • Geena Davis – 'a delight,' clearly headed for bigger things despite being relegated to a bit part.
  • George Wendt and Dana Wheeler-Nicholson also considered.
Apex Mountain
  • Chevy Chase – two apexes: SNL Season 1 and 1985-86 ('Fletch', European Vacation, Spies Like Us, Three Amigos).
  • Harold Faltermeyer – 'Beverly Hills Cop' + 'Fletch' leading to 'Top Gun'.
  • Kareem Abdul-Jabbar – 1985 (wins title, Finals MVP, scoring record, in 'Fletch') is a strong contender.
  • Venice Beach – right before it falls apart.
Picking nits
  • Gail Stanwyck's terrible tennis – the worst tennis anyone has ever played.
  • Gail being completely unfazed when 'Fletch' reveals her husband is a fraud.
  • Why does 'Fletch' hate Tommy Lasorda? – explained by a cut fantasy sequence.
Re-casting couch
  • Flip Geena Davis and Dana Wheeler-Nicholson – the movie would be better if Davis played Gail Stanwyck.
  • Elisabeth Shue or Sharon Stone also suggested for Gail.
(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • What is the correct spelling of 'John Cocteau Stone'? – debate over Cocktoastone, Cocteau Stone, or Cocktolstoy.
  • Did 'Fletch' actually retire from the newspaper at the end?
Who won the movie?

Chevy Chase – unanimous. Dana Wheeler-Nicholson in second place.

Half-assed (internet) research
  • Stanwyck's mansion is the same house from 'The Godfather' horse head scene.
  • A cut fantasy sequence had 'Fletch' pitching in the World Series with Tommy Lasorda pulling him.
  • Original poster showed 'Fletch' as a hockey player – never in the final cut.