September 16, 2020
'Easy A'
The Ringer's Juliet Litman, Amanda Dobbins, and Shea Serrano fake rock your world after rewatching one of the last great teen movies, 'Easy A,' starring Emma Stone, Amanda Bynes, and Penn Badgley.

Cast
Emma Stone as Olive Penderghast
Amanda Bynes as Marianne
Stanley Tucci as Dill Penderghast
Patricia Clarkson as Rosemary Penderghast
Thomas Haden Church as Mr. Griffith
Lisa Kudrow as Mrs. Griffith
Penn Badgley as Woodchuck Todd
Directed by: Will Gluck
Notes
- Amanda Bynes's final film before stepping away from acting. She reportedly didn't like her performance in 'Easy A' and decided not to act anymore.
- The script was allegedly written in five consecutive days by Bert Royal.
- Emma Stone allegedly auditioned via webcam – connects to the movie's own webcam framing device.
- Jennifer Lawrence auditioned for Olive. Extensive discussion about why she wouldn't work as well – different skill set than Emma Stone's 'performative' quality.
- Filmed on location in Ojai, California. Premiere at TIFF. Rated PG-13 (curse words were cut).
- The hosts argue Emma Stone should have been nominated for a Best Actress Oscar in 2010.
Categories
Most re-watchable scene
- Shea: The 'Pocketful of Sunshine' montage – Olive alone in her room playing the greeting card song over and over, growing to love it.
- Amanda: The 'Knock on Wood' musical number – Emma Stone's capital-M Movie Star moment.
- Juliet: The 'twat' kitchen scene – Olive tells her parents she used inappropriate language in class.
- Shea (runner-up): The confessional/webcam scene where Olive gets emotional – 'a lot of people hate me now. I kind of hate me, too.'
What aged the best?
- The YouTube/blogging/webcam framing device – still feels prescient and spot-on, not dated at all.
- Picking Ojai as the location – it has since become a very trendy, wealthy enclave.
- Emma Stone's wardrobe – both regular outfits and 'slutty' outfits still have a place in fashion.
- Emma Stone's performance overall – one of the best comedic performances of the decade.
What aged the worst?
- Amanda Bynes's character Marianne being defined by her Christianity – felt like stereotyping.
- The Mr. and Mrs. Griffith/Micah plot – the guidance counselor giving a student chlamydia is 'super weird' and unnecessary.
- The Huckleberry Finn references – dehumanizing treatment of the two Black men in the movie.
- The treatment of Chip, the adopted younger brother – Stanley Tucci's adoption jokes felt uncomfortable.
Casting what-ifs
- Jennifer Lawrence auditioned for Olive – extensive discussion about why Emma Stone works better in this role.
- Logan Lerman auditioned for Brandon (played by Dan Byrd).
Best "that guy"
- Shea and Amanda: Cam Gigandet – to Shea he's the bully from Never Back Down, to Amanda he's one of the Twilight guys.
- Juliet: Dan Byrd – recognizes him from the Hilary Duff Cinderella remake.
- Malcolm McDowell as the principal – runner-up.
Over-acting award
- Juliet: Patricia Clarkson – 'takes it too far' in the scene trying to find out if Brandon is gay.
- Amanda: Lisa Kudrow – when she's yelling 'Who would you believe?' at the end.
- Shea: Stanley Tucci.
Best "heat check" performance
- Patricia Clarkson and Stanley Tucci together – their chemistry as Olive's parents is 'a miracle.'
- Lisa Kudrow – probably two days of work and she made an impact.
Re-casting couch
For a modern version of Olive: Amanda picks Zendaya or Florence Pugh; Shea picks Isabela Merced.
Apex Mountain
- Not Emma Stone's Apex Mountain – this is where it starts for her, but La La Land/the Oscar win is the apex.
- Probably Will Gluck's Apex Mountain – he went on to Friends with Benefits and Peter Rabbit, but this is likely his peak.
Picking nits
- The 8th grade flashback – Olive not remembering 8th grade when it was only ~3 years ago.
- The party scene – the popular girl casually offering her bedroom for sex is not believable.
- 11th graders caring that someone had sex – not realistic.
(Probably) unanswerable questions
- Why don't we get to meet Olive's brother who's in college?
- Where did Lisa Kudrow's character get chlamydia?
Who won the movie?
Emma Stone, unanimously. 'Emma Stone 2010, you are the Cornerstone of our Teen Movie rebuild.'