March 11, 2019

'Broadcast News'

The Ringer's Bill Simmons, Chuck Klosterman, Chris Ryan, and Sean Fennessey deliver the hard-hitting facts as they rewatch the James Brooks directed comedy classic 'Broadcast News,' starring Holly Hunter, William Hurt, and Albert Brooks.

Movie poster

Cast

Holly Hunter as Jane Craig

William Hurt as Tom Grunick

Albert Brooks as Aaron Altman

Jack Nicholson as Bill Rorish

Joan Cusack as Blair Litton

Robert Prosky as Ernie Merriman

Directed by: James L. Brooks

Written by: James L. Brooks

Cinematography by: Michael Ballhaus

Music by: Bill Conti

Notes

  • $15 million budget, made $67 million. 98% on Rotten Tomatoes. Seven Oscar nominations but zero wins – shut out. Holly Hunter lost Best Actress to Cher for Moonstruck, Albert Brooks lost Best Supporting Actor to Sean Connery for 'The Untouchables', and Jim Brooks wasn't even nominated for Best Director despite the film getting seven nominations.
  • The Holly Hunter character is based on Susan Zirinsky (who now runs CBS News), whom Jim Brooks met at political conventions in 1984. She was dating two guys at the same time who worked in TV. Brooks spent years embedding with Washington and New York media circles, and was so thorough that everyone he interviewed thought the movie was about them.
  • Debra Winger was originally cast as Jane but got pregnant and had to leave. Holly Hunter was cast as a replacement. Her 1987 was extraordinary: 'Broadcast News' and Raising Arizona in the same year.
  • Jack Nicholson was unpaid for his role at his own request. Only listed in the end credits – they didn't sell the movie with him at all.
  • Albert Brooks phoned Jim Brooks at 3 AM after watching a CNN reporter sweat badly on air. That became the sweating scene. Jim Brooks made them do 24 takes because he thought it was the key part of the movie.
  • Jim Brooks tried to surprise Holly Hunter with an alternate ending: William Hurt jumped into the cab at the end and they ad-libbed a scene where they make out. A crew member accidentally said 'Bill' before the camera rolled and ruined it. Both Hurt and Hunter later said they wished the movie had used that ending.
  • The film has a deleted alternate ending on YouTube. 'Switching Channels' (1988) with Kathleen Turner and Burt Reynolds was a quasi-competitor that bombed and started a Kathleen Turner slide.

Categories

Roger Ebert's review

Quote from Rog's review:

Broadcast News is as knowledgeable about the TV news-gathering process as any movie ever made, but it also has insights into the more human side of television.

Four out of four stars. 'He crushed this one.'

Most re-watchable scene
  • Aaron's apartment fight with Jane – about 8 minutes long and feels like one take. The peaks and valleys, the devil monologue ('What do you think the devil's going to look like?'), and 'I would give anything if you were two people so I could call up the one who's my friend and tell her about the one that I like so much.'
  • The first time William Hurt anchors and Holly Hunter is in his ear, with Albert Brooks calling on the phone.
  • The Bobby Bobby Bobby scene – Joan Cusack running the tape to the booth, told entirely from William Hurt's point of view as he's thrown into the deep end of live producing.
  • Aaron's television disaster – the sweating scene. The bar everyone pointed to of what you don't want to happen on live TV.
  • William Hurt and Albert Brooks on the balcony – 'Can you name all the members of the cabinet?' 'Yes, Aaron.' 'OK, all 12.' 'There's only 10.'
  • Jane confronting Tom about the video trick with the tears – his face when he realizes what she's mad about.
What aged the best?
  • The theme of an unkillable media institution starting to die – the central problem of working in media, still completely relevant.
  • Aaron's theory that the devil would be attractive, nice, and helpful, and would just bit by little bit lower our standards where they're important.
  • The Holly Hunter character – anyone who's worked in media has run across this person. Just calm down and have a drink. You can go home. 'Doesn't work like that.'
  • All three characters as archetypes: the guy who's too smart to succeed, the guy who succeeds because he's not that smart, and the woman caught between them.
  • The ending – 'no one wins' was bold in 1987 and feels even bolder now.
  • Joan Cusack saying 'Except for socially, you're my role model.'
  • The Nicholson reaction when someone suggests cutting $1 million from his salary.
What aged the worst?
  • The office romance dynamics – Jane is technically Tom's boss and they almost hook up. In 2019 that's a fireable offense.
  • Aaron being dismissive of the date rape segment as 'not real news' – in 2019 that absolutely is news.
  • Holly Hunter's hair and dress at the correspondents dinner – Bill's wife audibly gasped.
  • Holly Hunter sending Lois Chiles' character to Alaska to keep her away from Tom – a potential HR lawsuit now.
  • The opening childhood scenes – very sitcom-y, would definitely get cut if the movie were made today.
Casting what-ifs
  • Debra Winger was originally cast as Jane Craig but got pregnant. The hosts don't think this movie works with Winger – too much history, too many 80s movies.
  • Also considered for Jane: Sigourney Weaver, Judy Davis, Elizabeth McGovern, Christine Lahti, Elizabeth Perkins.
  • You could see Harrison Ford doing the William Hurt role. Or Luke Wilson.
Best "heat check" performance
  • Jack Nicholson – maybe the greatest heat check performer in the history of American cinema. Between this, Reds, 'A Few Good Men', Terms of Endearment, and the Joker, no one can take over a movie with less screen time. Unpaid, only listed in end credits, just wearing a suit reading news, and every time he's on screen you can't look away.
  • Joan Cusack – the running scene, the Jurgen Klinsmann slide under the filing cabinet. Incredibly memorable for how little screen time she has.
Best "that guy"
  • Bob Prosky – one of the great Mamet actors. Sinister in Thief, then became good grandpa. His scenes where he tells Aaron about the layoffs and then Aaron says 'I need to go be alone' and Prosky says 'OK, I'll join you' are wonderful.
  • William Hurt's dad – great in a tiny role from Tucson.
  • Christian Clemenson as the control room guy who looks like Philip Seymour Hoffman and loves getting compliments from Tom.
Half-assed (internet) research
  • Albert Brooks watching CNN at 3 AM saw a reporter sweating badly on air, called Jim Brooks and said Aaron had to start sweating – that became the key scene.
  • Jack Nicholson unpaid for his role at his own request.
  • Jim Brooks made them do 24 takes of the sweating scene.
  • The alternate ending was almost captured in one take but a crew member said 'Bill' right before they rolled.
  • One of the music composer guys in the movie is Marc Shaiman, who went on to write all the songs in Mary Poppins Returns.
Apex Mountain
  • Jim Brooks – fully established as an A-list movie director while already in the TV Hall of Fame. A year away from The Simpsons. This is the perfect inflection point.
  • Holly Hunter – this and Raising Arizona in the same year. Even over The Piano (Oscar), this movie had more lasting cultural impact.
  • William Hurt – indisputably. The first eight years of his career are almost incomparable.
  • Albert Brooks – tentative yes, though his directorial work might edge it.
Over-acting award

Tough category for this movie because everyone dials it up but it never feels like overacting. The closest is the Aaron apartment scene where he yells 'Get out of here! You go to hell!' – but that's just authentic losing your shit on somebody.

Picking nits
  • The ending – seven years is too long. Four would have been better. And Tom's fiance is a letdown – he should have been married to a 22-year-old smoke-show weather lady.
  • Why didn't Holly Hunter smoke? This character was dying to be smoking cigs. Diet Coke and cigarettes in an 87 office – it would have pushed the character to the next level.
(Probably) unanswerable questions
  • Did Holly Hunter die alone? She says there's a guy at the end, but Bill thinks she made that up.
  • What is the best movie of the 1980s? The hosts spiral into a 15-minute debate. Sean makes a strong case for 'Broadcast News'. 'Back to the Future', Raiders, 'Die Hard', and Bull Durham all come up.
Who won the movie?

Holly Hunter – you can't substitute anyone for her. Her height, her energy, her specific personality. You could see Jeff Bridges playing the William Hurt part at 95%, but nobody else could do what Holly Hunter does. Close second: Albert Brooks, because you also can't replace him. Jim Brooks has a case too for essentially inventing the modern love triangle dramedy.

Sequel, prequel, prestige TV or untouchable?

They already made it – it's called The Newsroom. Same DNA, but the problem was Jeff Daniels was the star instead of the Holly Hunter character. Sean says the show had 'a pebble in its shoe' and never got a full episode right.